Events
The applicant, who was a university student at the time of the events, was given a one-month suspension from the higher education institution due to his words and behaviors towards the rector of the university. The applicant filed a lawsuit in the administrative court for the annulment of this administrative act, and the court decided to reject the case, stating that there was no illegality in the action subject to the case, on the grounds that the words of the applicant were of a nature to damage the honor and reputation of the university rector. The applicant’s appeal request was also rejected by the regional administrative court.
allegations
The applicant alleges that imposing a disciplinary sanction due to his words and behaviors towards the rector of the university he is a student at violates his right to education.
Court’s Evaluation
In the concrete case, the applicant stated that he was responsible for the dismissal of many academics from the university, and claimed that he used his right to democratic criticism against the rector, and that he did not make any insulting remarks during his peaceful protest. The applicant stated that since the rector did not go to the areas where the students spent time at the university and did not meet with the students, he showed the model he had made with his friends among the students in the faculty, and that he ended his protest when the security guards took the model. During the trial, the courts did not touch upon the issue of where the line between the right to legitimate criticism and defamation lies.
The Constitutional Court has adopted some principles that should be taken into account in criticism of public authorities or public policies. Even if some of the opinions and expressions first expressed are deemed unacceptable in the eyes of the organs that exercise public power, ideas that oppose the established order, policies and practices in a democratic society established on the basis of the rule of law or that criticize the actions of organs that use public power and find them unacceptable should be freely expressed. Secondly, it should not be forgotten that the limits of acceptable criticism of public authorities-because they use public power- are much wider than those of private individuals. Thirdly, public authorities have the opportunity to respond and react to criticisms directed at them through different means.
In the concrete case, the applicant criticized from a certain point of view the dismissal of some academics from the university and their punishment with disciplinary penalties. The statements in question are directed at issues of public interest. On the other hand, in the words and behaviors subject to the application, a sarcastic language was used against the rector and an action containing satire was made. Even if it is claimed to be offensive at first glance, it cannot be said that the statements in question are unfoundedly injurious to others, offensive and inappropriate. However, the court of first instance concluded that the expressions used were of a nature to damage the honor and dignity of the persons; however, he did not discuss which words would damage the honor and dignity of the rector and for what reasons the applicant could not benefit from the protection of his freedom of expression. However, in the statement that is the subject of the application -based on some facts that are not claimed to be wrong by the administration- the actions of the rector were cynically criticized.
In the decisions of the administration and the courts regarding the disciplinary punishments to be given to university students, they must also show the possible or existing negative effects of the action subject to the intervention on the order of the educational institution. In the concrete case, it has not been revealed in the court decisions to which compulsory social need the disciplinary punishment given corresponds. As a result, the applicant was punished with expulsion from school due to his use of his freedom of expression and could not benefit from his right to education. The justifications put forward by the courts were not considered relevant and sufficient for the interference with the applicant’s right to education.
The Constitutional Court decided that the right to education was violated for the reasons explained.
You can reach our other article samples and petition samples by clicking here.