Events
The operating license of Asya Katılım Bankası Anonim Şirketi (Bank) was revoked by the Banking Regulation and Supervision Agency (BDDK) on 22/7/2016 pursuant to Articles 106 and 107 of the Banking Law No. 5411 and the Bank was transferred to the Savings Deposit Insurance Fund (TMSF). . With the decision of the SDIF dated 24/11/2016 on the participation fund in the bank, it was blocked as a precautionary measure on the grounds of doubtful receivables.
The applicant, who has three separate accounts, one of which is a special current account and the other two of which is a participation account, and an investigation has been initiated and an arrest warrant has been issued for membership in the Fetullah Terrorist Organization/Parallel State Structure (FETÖ/PDY). applied and requested that if there is a blockage on the participation fund, it should be removed by stating its legal basis. The applicant filed a lawsuit in the administrative court upon the rejection of his application for the removal of the block; The court dismissed the applicant’s request. The applicant’s appeal against this decision was also definitively rejected by the regional administrative court.
allegations
the applicant; He claimed that his property right was violated due to the blocking of the participation fund amount in a bank that was decided to be transferred to the SDIF.
Court’s Evaluation
In the concrete case, the court examined whether the accounts within the scope of insurance from the participation funds held at the Bank were related to FETÖ/PDY or whether they were intended to support the organization, and that there was no illegality in the blocked transaction established as a precaution until the investigation is concluded and the doubts about the accuracy of the accounts are eliminated. concluded. According to the SDIF’s reply dated 25/11/2021, it is understood that the measure was not lifted, but later, in the reply dated 4/4/2022, it was stated that the measure was lifted. Therefore, the complaint against the injunction decision, which was made by the SDIF’s decision dated 24/11/2016 and which was understood to have been lifted after 25/11/2021, was evaluated in terms of whether the intervention was proportional in the context of the length of the measure period.
When Article 63 of Law No. 5411 and Article 10 of the Regulation are evaluated together, the following conclusions are reached. The accuracy of the deposit and participation fund accounts held at the credit institutions whose operating licenses have been revoked will be examined by the commission in accordance with the procedure stated in paragraph (1) of Article 10 of the Regulation. The evaluation of the insured deposits and insured participation funds by the Commission, the determinations and decisions of the BRSA and judicial and administrative authorities, the documents submitted by the account holders, the records kept before the Insurance and Risk Monitoring Department, the bank records and other relevant documents It will be completed within three months from the date the activity permit is revoked. This period may be extended for three months when necessary, and if the three-month extension period is insufficient due to compulsory reasons, this period may be extended two more times by the SDIF Fund Board, not exceeding three months each. Accordingly, it is clear that a decision should be made regarding the accuracy of the deposit and participation fund accounts at the end of one year at the latest from the date the bank’s operating license was revoked by the commission. However, in the concrete case, from 22/7/2016, when it was decided to revoke the operating license of the Bank, until 25/11/2021, no decision was made regarding the accuracy of the deposit and participation fund accounts of the applicant, and information indicating that any research or examination was carried out in accordance with the procedure specified in the Regulation, or The document has not been found.
In order to be able to mention that the measures taken on the property values of individuals are proportional, there should be a reasonable justification for the action and the reasons justifying the continuation of these decisions should also be presented. In addition, due to the length of the period, the measure must not become disproportionate and therefore unmeasured. In the instant case, the court of instance rejected the request for the annulment of the injunction on the grounds that the investigation regarding the accuracy of the accounts was still ongoing. When the court’s reasoning is examined, it is seen that there is no evaluation on whether the SDIF made an examination in accordance with the provisions of Article 63 of Law No. 5411 and Article 10 of the Regulation, and whether there are reasons justifying the continuation of the measure. Therefore, it was understood that the SDIF transactions were not audited and the injunction continued for a period of more than 5 years and 4 months. To mention that the duration of the injunction on the applicant’s bank account, which lasts for a period of more than 5 years and 4 months, is predictable and reasonable, in the face of the failure to determine that there is a fault attributable to the applicant in the long-term duration of the measure, and the failure to present a justification for exceeding the one-year period specified in the Regulation. It is not possible. Therefore, it has been concluded that the long-term continuation of the injunction imposed on the applicant personally imposes an excessive burden on the applicant, therefore, the intervention has upset the fair balance that should exist between the public interest and the protection of the applicant’s property right, and is not proportionate.
The Constitutional Court decided that the right to property had been violated for the reasons explained.
You can reach our other article samples and petition samples by clicking here.