TITLE DEED CANCELLATION AND REGISTRATION CASE DUE TO DELEGATE’S LICENSE
It is self-evident how important the determination of a person’s capacity is in terms of the consequences of the law of person and property. In this case, it is obligatory to collect all the evidence to be shown by the parties, to obtain explanatory and satisfactory concrete information in this direction from the witnesses, to bring the doctor’s reports, patient observation (observation) papers, film graphs, if any, belonging to the alleged incompetent person. Besides that, although 6100 p. As stated in Article 282 of the Code of Civil Procedure, although the “vote and opinion” of the expert does not bind the judge, it can be attributed not only to biological causes such as lack of appeal power, minor age, mental illness, mental weakness, drunkenness, but also to psychological factors such as consciousness, comprehension and will. due to mental illness,
Especially, the fact that the power of discrimination is a relative concept and changes according to the action and process of the person makes it necessary to obtain a report from the most authorized health board in this direction, especially the Fourth Specialization Board of the Forensic Medicine Institute. Essentially 409/2. Article stipulates that mental illness or mental weakness will be determined by an expert report.
Considering that the legal incompetence is related to the public order, it is necessary to examine firstly based on its importance, to collect all the evidence to be reported by the parties in this direction, if any, health board reports of the legator, patient observation papers, prescriptions, etc. The entire file is sent to the Forensic Medicine Institute in accordance with the provisions of Articles 7 and 16 of the Law No. 2659, receiving a report on whether the legator is competent on the contract date, if it is understood that he is incapacitated, the cancellation and registration lawsuits to be filed based on the legal reason for the incompetence are filed in the name of the estate. Turkish Civil Code 701 et al. Considering that it is in accordance with the provisions of the Articles of Association and that there is no possibility of hearing the lawsuit based on the share, if it is understood that it is competent, an investigation is made in terms of collusion allegations, which are the other legal grounds based on the case, The collection of party evidence on whether the assignment transaction between the testator and the defendant … is collusive, according to the evidence collected and to be collected; If it is determined that the assignment is fraudulent, it is not correct to evaluate whether the defendant, the owner of the last registration, is in good faith and whether he will benefit from the protection of Article 1023, and a decision should be made according to the result to be reached, but it is not correct to make a decision as written with a wrong evaluation and incomplete research (Court of Appeals 1st Civil Chamber). – Decision: 2017/1475).
INCAPACITY AND ABUSE OF POWER OF ATTORNEY
It is understood from the way the claim is put forward and the content of the lawsuit petition that the legal reasons for incompetence and abuse of power of attorney are based on legal grounds.
As emphasized in the decision of the General Assembly of the Court of Cassation, dated 11.04.1990 and numbered 1990/1-152-1990/236, there is, in principle, no procedural or unlawful aspect in showing several legal reasons together in terms of the material facts based on the case.
On the other hand, considering that legal incompetence is related to public order, it should be examined first due to its importance.
As known; It cannot be mentioned that a person who does not have the power (power) to understand, evaluate and distinguish the causes and consequences of his behaviors, actions and transactions can establish a right with his own will, and be under a debt (obligation). As a matter of fact, the provision of Article 9 of the Turkish Civil Code (TMK), which states that “a person who has the capacity to act, can acquire rights and incur debts through his own actions”, has tied the ability to obtain rights and to be under debt (obligation). In Article 10, by accepting to be an adult with the power of discrimination as the main condition of the capacity to act, “an adult person who has the power to distinguish and who is not limited has the capacity to act.” brought its verdict. “Distinguished power” is also defined as the capacity to act and function, and according to Article 13 of the same Law. According to this law, “everyone who is not incapable of acting rationally because of minor age or because of mental illness, mental weakness, drunkenness, or the like, has the power of discernment under this law.” Also, some of the important reasons that remove the power of discrimination are mentioned. Because of their importance, these principles were also included in various provisions of the said law and other laws.
It should be noted right away that, as stated in Article 15, the goodwill of the other party does not make that transaction valid, since no result can be concluded due to the fact that the person who does not have the power to discriminate does not have a valid will, without prejudice to the discrete circumstances indicated in the law. This principle was adopted in the Supreme Court Judgment Unification Decision dated 11.06.1941 and numbered 4/21.
When approaching the event in the light of the above-mentioned principles and articles of law; It is self-evident how important the determination of a person’s capacity is in terms of its consequences in terms of person and property law. It is obligatory to bring complete patient observation (observation) papers and film graphics. In addition, although the “vote and opinion” of the expert does not bind the judge, as stated in Article 282 of the Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, it is not only due to biological reasons such as lack of appeal power, young age, mental illness, mental weakness, drunkenness, but also to consciousness. , understanding,
Especially, the fact that the power of discrimination is a relative concept and changes according to the action and process of the person makes it necessary to obtain a report from the most authorized health board in this direction, especially the Fourth Specialization Board of the Forensic Medicine Institute. Essentially 409/2. Article stipulates that mental illness or mental weakness will be determined by an expert report. As for the concrete case; According to the medical board report dated 14.03.2007 received from the Ceyhan State Hospital, the court concluded that the plaintiff was incapable.
When this happens; First of all, collecting all the evidence to be declared by the parties in terms of legal incapacity, requesting the medical board reports of the plaintiff, patient observation papers, prescriptions, etc., sending the entire file to the Forensic Medicine Institute, receiving a report on whether the plaintiff is competent in the power of attorney and drawing contract dates, understanding that he is competent. In the event of a disputed parcel no. 23, the allegations of abuse of power of attorney should be examined and a decision should be made based on the result, but it is not correct to make a written judgment based on an incomplete investigation (Court of Appeals 1st Civil Chamber – Decision: 2016/2135).