PENAL CLAUSE IN LABOR LAW
At this point, it should be stated that the Supreme Court has produced solutions specific to labor law in some respects, with established case-laws. As a result of the “Interpretation Principle for the Benefit of the Worker” in labor law, the penal clauses that impose liability only against the worker were deemed invalid and the precedents settled in this direction were also adopted in the doctrine. While there is no clear provision in the Code of Obligations No. 818 regarding the penal clause in terms of service contracts, Article 420 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 states that “Only the penal clause placed against the employee in the service contracts is invalid.” introduced the regulation. In this respect, only the penal conditions against the employee in the service contracts should be considered invalid, and the penal conditions in favor of the employee should be considered valid.
The necessity of arranging the penal clause on both the employee and the employer, also reveals the result that the penal clause decided against the worker should not be more than the one decided against the employer. In other words, the penal clause determined against the employee cannot be considered to exceed the employer’s responsibility in terms of its conditions and the amount of the penalty. In the event of an inequality against the worker in a bilateral penal clause, although the penal clause is not completely invalid, the worker’s liability cannot exceed the amount and circumstances for which the employer is responsible.
It is seen that the penal clause determined in the labor law is generally brought in order to prevent the termination of the employment contract for a certain period of time without a just cause, to claim the training expenses in case the minimum working condition of the worker is not complied with, or to ensure that the non-competition agreement is complied with. In all these cases, the parties assume a contractual obligation and the effectiveness of the commitments is ensured with the penal clause (Canbolat/Erener, p. 230).
In the concrete dispute, which is the subject of the application, the similar penal clause regulation in the employment contracts is as follows: “In case of termination of the contract by the employer with or without notice, the employer shall pay the employee compensation equal to the 6 (six) monthly net wage, in addition to the compensations required by the Turkish labor legislation and all other rights”. In the first decision of the regional court of appeal, it was concluded that the said penal clause was invalid on the grounds that it was not reciprocal, while in the other decision, it was concluded that the penal clause was valid only because there was no need for reciprocity in terms of the penal clause in favor of the worker.
As explained in detail above, although only the penal clause stipulated against the worker in labor law is invalid, only the penal clause stipulated in favor of the worker is valid. In this respect, the penal clause stipulated in employment contracts in concrete disputes is valid only because it is regulated in favor of the worker.
LOWERING THE PENAL CLAUSE
As it is seen, the first paragraph of the above article has set the principle of freedom in determining the amount of penal clause; On the other hand, in the last paragraph, it has drawn a special limit through the right to freedom.
When investigating whether the penalty is excessive and whether it exceeds the criteria of equity, the judge especially takes into account the damage suffered by the creditor due to the breach of debt, the degree of fault of the debtor, the common fault of the creditor and the economic situation of the parties (especially the debtor). When these factors are taken into account, if there is a clear disproportion between the damage suffered by the creditor and the agreed penalty, the penalty is reduced. When assessing whether the penal clause is excessive, it should be taken into account that the purpose of the penal clause is to improve the creditor’s situation. While reducing the agreed penalty, in any case, the amount of compensation that the creditor can request according to the general rules should be exceeded in order to cover his positive loss. The possibility of reducing the excessive penal clause, It is a rule of public order aimed at preventing the exploitation of the weak debtor. Therefore, the debtor’s “pre-waiver of the possibility of downloading” is invalid (Reisoğlu, S: General Provisions of the Law of Obligations, Istanbul, 2004, p:391,392, referring to Oser-Schönenberger, Tunçomağ, Becker, von Tuhr).
On the other hand, in accordance with Article 24 of the TCC, although the debtor with the title of merchant cannot demand the reduction of the penal clause, if it is (heavy) and (high) enough to cause the commercial destruction of the indebted merchant and not allow him to continue his commercial activities as before, then, accepting such a (penal clause) as a condition contrary to morals and morals, it is possible to cancel it (partially) or (completely). Because, the (criminal clause) included in the contract due to violation of morals and morals is a general principle of law. It is not possible to think that the provision of Article 24 of the TCC will be excluded from this general sanction. Every (criminal condition) that reaches a level that will endanger or destroy a debtor’s economic and commercial activity and existence is contrary to morals and morals.
While the court decides on this matter, if the debtor is a company, by summoning the company’s trade registry (articles of association), the amount of capital it carries out in commercial activities, what its assets are related to, and in case of collection of the agreed penal clause, that company will be subject to commercial transactions as before. If necessary, it is necessary to investigate whether it is possible for him to continue his life, by taking the opinion of the expert, and he should do the same examination for a real person (trader) (Doğanay, 237). It should be noted that in order for the provision of Article 24 of the TCC to be applicable, the debtor must have the title of merchant or be in a position to be liable as a merchant at the time the penal clause or fee or interest is determined and determined. In addition, the penal clause of the debtor,
It should be emphasized that; The moment to be taken as a basis while investigating whether the title of merchant is present is the moment when the penal clause is committed, not the moment of maturity. In this respect, if the promiser has become a trader after undertaking the penal clause, he is authorized to request a download. On the other hand, a person who loses his title as a trader after committing a penal clause cannot request a reduction, and a person who takes the penal clause debt and is not a merchant is not authorized to request a reduction.
In the concrete case, although the defendants claimed that they were not traffickers and requested that the right of discretionary reduction be taken into consideration within the scope of Article 182 of the TCO, it was not investigated whether the defendants … and … were traders within the scope of the file, and whether the penal clause could be considered exorbitant, and therefore it should be reduced by the court in sufficient concrete terms. It is understood that it is not discussed based on the data. No judgment can be made with incomplete examination, justifications that are not suitable for auditing, subjective expressions and abstract statements. In this case, within the framework of Articles 14, 17, 1463 of the TCC and Article 3 of the Law No. 5362 on Tradesmen and Craftsmen Professional Organizations, by investigating whether the defendants are merchants or not; If it is determined whether the penal clause will cause the defendants to collapse economically or not, if it is determined that they are not a trader;