INVESTIGATION OF EVIDENCE IN DEED CANCELLATION CASE OPENED DUE TO INCOMPETENCE
The basis of the title deed cancellation and registration lawsuit is the claim that the defendant bought real estate from a person who does not have the power to appeal. As it is stated in Article 15 of the Turkish Civil Code No. 4721, the goodwill of the other party does not make that transaction valid, since the transaction to be made cannot be concluded due to the fact that the person who does not have the power of discrimination does not have a valid will, without prejudice to the discrete situations indicated in the law. This principle was also adopted in the Supreme Court Judgment Unification Decision dated 11.6.1941 and numbered 4/21.
In this case, it is obligatory to collect all the evidence to be shown by the parties, to obtain explanatory and satisfactory concrete information from the witnesses in this direction, to bring the doctor’s reports, patient observation papers, film graphs, if any, belonging to the alleged incompetent person. In addition, although the “vote and opinion” of the expert does not bind the judge, as stated in Article 282 of the Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 ( HMK ), the absence of the power to appeal, minor age, mental illness , mental weakness , drunkenness . Determination of biological and related psychological causes such as mental illness and mental weakness often requires special and technical knowledge outside the profession of judge.
Considering that the license is related to public order and considering its importance, it should be examined first, collecting all the evidence to be reported by the parties in this direction, medical board reports of the legator, if any, patient observation papers, prescriptions, etc. to send the entire file to the 4th Specialization Board of the Forensic Medicine Institute in accordance with the provisions of Articles 7 and 16 of the Law No. 2659, to receive a report on whether the legator is competent on the contract date, to evaluate the request based on the legal reason of the inheritor’s collusion, if it is determined that the legator is competent, to complete the investigation, While the decision should be made according to the result that will result, it is against the law to make a decision by ignoring the aforementioned issues. (Court of Appeals 1st Civil Chamber – Decision No: 2015/7013).
WHO CAN FILE THE CASE FOR CANCELLATION OF DEED DUE TO INCOMPETENCE?
While the capacity to party is related to the personalities of the parties to the case, the title of party is related to the subjective right that is the subject of the lawsuit. Even if the person shown as a party in a lawsuit has the capacity to be a party, if that person does not really have the title of being a plaintiff or a defendant in that lawsuit, no decision can be made on the merits of the right that is the subject of the lawsuit. The decision to reject the case due to lack of title is not a decision that the case cannot be heard, but a decision on the merits that determines the absence of the capacity of a party.
Accordingly, the lawsuit for cancellation and registration of title deed about an immovable property can only be filed by the person who relies on the right of ownership on that immovable, and whether the party requesting the deed cancellation and registration in the case is really the owner of that right should be observed ex officio by the court at every stage of the case. far from stopping.
In the concrete case, the plaintiffs claimed that the assignment of their father, who was alive on the date of the lawsuit, to the defendant was invalid due to incapacity, and requested the registration of the immovable in the name of their surviving father, with the cancellation of the title deed registration. Since the person who made the assignment and who is actually entitled is alive, the right to bring any kind of lawsuit based on this assignment belongs exclusively to him.
In such a case, since there is a claim of legal incapacity, it is a legal obligation to appoint a guardian to the limited real right holder who is alive and to represent him in legal proceedings by obtaining permission from the guardianship authority.
From this point of view, the plaintiffs’ father, Mehmet Coşkun, is alive as of the date of the lawsuit and has the capacity to be a party within the framework of the legal facts explained above; therefore, there is no doubt that an action for annulment and registration can only be filed by him or the guardian authorized to represent him, based on the claim of ownership in terms of the immovable property subject to the lawsuit.
As such, in the case at hand, the plaintiffs, on behalf of their father, who was legally a party on the date of the lawsuit, unlawfully presented themselves as a party and requested the title deed cancellation and registration; It is also not possible to remedy the procedural deficiency, which is the condition of this lawsuit, which exists as of the date of the lawsuit, by appointing a representative to the estate due to the death of the father during the trial.
On the other hand, the right to sue the immovable property of the plaintiffs, who are the rightful owners of the immovable property and sue on behalf of their father, who is alive as of the date of the case; It is also clear that the adjectives of the plaintiff do not exist in the same way.
As such; While the decision to reverse the Special Chamber, which was adopted by the Local Court and also by the General Assembly of Laws, pointing to the necessity of rejecting the case, should be followed, it is against the procedure and the law to resist the previous decision to accept the case on the merits. Therefore, the decision to resist should be reversed (YHGK-K.2010/337).