CONDITIONS FOR REDUCTION OF PENAL CLAUSE IN COMMERCIAL LAW
The penal clause [the term in the Turkish Code of Obligations (TBK) and the penal clause] is regulated between Articles 158 and 161 of the same Law.
A penal clause is a separate act with a financial value that must be paid in case of non-performance or incomplete performance of the existing debt. It is possible to easily deduce the elements of the penal clause from this description. These elements are; it really consists of the existence of a principal debt, the existence of a separate and independent act, the interdependence of these two, and the determination of this separate and independent act in a transaction that has a bearing on health (Tunçomağ, p. 6).
The penal clause is an accessory to the main debt; It is an act connected to it but separate from it and it is not necessary for the damage to occur in order for the penal clause to be realized.
Article 158 of the repealed Code of Obligations No. 818 regulates three different penal conditions. These are the optional penal clause, the penal clause added to the performance and the penal clause preventing the performance.
In the 161st article of the repealed Code of Obligations No. 818, titled “The Exemption and Criticism of Punishment”; “The contracts are free to determine the amount of the penalty. If the penalty is stipulated to confirm a debt contrary to law or morality (adaba), or if the performance of the debt is impossible due to a situation that does not necessitate the liability of the debtor, the payment of the stipulated penalty cannot be demanded. The judge is liable to criticize the punishments he deems exorbitant.”
Its provision is included.
When investigating whether the penalty is excessive and whether it exceeds the criteria of equity, the judge especially takes into account the damage suffered by the creditor due to the breach of debt, the degree of fault of the debtor, the common fault of the creditor and the economic situation of the parties (especially the debtor). When these factors are taken into account, if there is a clear disproportion between the damage suffered by the creditor and the agreed penalty, the penalty is reduced. When assessing whether the penal clause is excessive, it should be taken into account that the purpose of the penal clause is to improve the creditor’s situation.
The provision of the first paragraph of Article 161 of the UK regarding the penal clause, after accepting the principle (The contracts are free to determine the amount of the penalty), made the judge obliged to criticize the punishment he deems exorbitant, with the provision of the third paragraph. However, the provision of Article 24 of the repealed Turkish Commercial Code (TCC) numbered 6762, which was in force at the date of signing the contract and which should be applied in terms of the concrete case, accepts the principle that the parties with the title of merchants can freely determine the amount (penal clause). they have adopted that they cannot demand the reduction of the sentence, that is, the criticism.
Article 24 of the abrogated Turkish Commercial Code No. 6762; “A debtor holding the title of merchant cannot ask the court to reduce a fee or penalty on the grounds that it is exorbitant, in the cases written in the 2nd paragraph of the 104th article of the Code of Obligations, the 3rd paragraph of the 161st article and the 409th article of the Code of Obligations.” contains the provision.
In our commercial law, the penal clause is limited only by the concept of “immorality” in Article 20 of the UK Code. Pursuant to Article 24 of the repealed TCC, it is not possible for the trader to demand the abatement of the penal clause he owes, however, the principle of freedom of contract granted to the person who is the trader and his contract with the aforementioned article includes the BK’s regulation of nullity, which is a limiting provision for all contracts. It is limited by the provision of Article 20.
If the amount of the penal clause determined by the contract by the parties is so heavy and high that it will cause the debtor’s financial ruin and will not allow him to continue his commercial activities as before, then such a penal clause shall be considered as a condition contrary to morality and morality. It is possible to cancel it partially or completely. Because the nullity of the penal clause in the contract due to violation of morals and morals is a general principle of law. It is not possible to think that the provision of Article 24 of the repealed TCC will be excluded from this general sanction. Any penal clause reaching a level that would endanger or destroy a debtor’s economic and commercial activity and existence is contrary to morality and good manners.
When deciding on this matter, the court should investigate whether it is possible for that company to continue its commercial life as before, if necessary, by taking the opinion of the expert, in case of collection of the agreed penal clause. The same should be done for the trader, who is a natural person. As a matter of fact, the same principles were adopted in the decision of the General Assembly of Law No. 2017/19-922 E., 2019/706 K. dated 18.06.2019.
When the concrete event is evaluated in the light of these principles and explanations; A sales contract was signed between the parties on 01.01.2012, and in article 16 of the contract, if the defendant operator does not operate the business partially or completely during the contract period, transfers the business or makes a job change in the business or violates any of the provisions specified in this agreement, the plaintiff company He will pay all of his debts in his records, financial aid, contributions and all kinds of fixed investment expenditures he has received from the company, as well as the discount amounts applied, together with the interest to be calculated, including the accrued interest from the date of issue, to the company in cash.
It is fixed that the defendant caused the breach of the contract due to the transfer of the business in violation of the contract during the continuation of the contract. However, while the court ruled against the defendant in penal clause due to the breach of the contract by the defendant, Article 22 of the TCC No. 6102 did not provide for a reduction from the penal clause, stating that the defendant was a merchant and that he had to act prudently while making the contract, although the penal clause did not deduct the penalty from the merchant debtor’s economic loss . If it is severe and high enough to cause destruction, it is possible for the court to decide to cancel the penal clause completely or partially, since this issue will be deemed against general morals and morals.
In this case, before making a decision on the penal clause, the court should decide on the outcome of the contract, taking into account the economic situation of the parties at the date of the contract, the solvency and ability of the defendant debtor, examining the defendant’s books and records in this regard, and obtaining an expert report in a manner suitable for auditing. The decision to resist given due to incomplete examination and erroneous justification is not appropriate.