BEGINNING OF EVIDENCE IN PROOF OF COVENANT OF FAITH
The parties to the fiduciary transaction are the believer and the believer. A person who faithfully transfers a right or object to a trusted person is called a “believer”. The person who uses the transferred right or object for his own benefit, directly or indirectly, as a right belonging to himself, is also called the “believer”. The right or object that the believer brings to the believer as a believer is described as the “thing that is the subject of belief”. In a fiduciary transaction, the parties of the profitable transaction and the parties of the debt-creating contract are the same. In the fiduciary transaction, the believer undertakes to comply with the conditions determined while exercising his right, and to transfer the right or object to the believer (or the third person indicated by him) when the purpose is realized or when the time expires. A fiduciary transaction, when certain conditions are fulfilled for the person who makes the gain, namely the believer, It is a contract that provides the right to demand a refund of the winnings. If this obligation is not fulfilled, it may be demanded to be fulfilled by litigation.
A contract of belief can only be proved with written evidence in accordance with the Supreme Court Judgment Unification Decision dated 05.02.1947 and numbered 20/6. This written evidence must be a document brought by the parties and bearing their signatures.
In this case, there is no written document signed between the parties stating that the immovable property in question belongs to the plaintiff and has been transferred to the defendant on condition of return. Although there is no written evidence of the declared nature, it is not considered sufficient to prove the whole of the dispute between the parties, but it is not considered sufficient to prove the occurrence of this (a promissory note or letter that is handwritten by the believer but not signed, a document that bears the initials of the believer, although it is written with a typewriter or computer. If there is a document in the nature of “beginning of evidence” (such as unapproved fingerprints or sealed bills), a belief agreement can be proved with all kinds of evidence, including “witness”, in accordance with Article 202 of HMK No. 6100.
Since the money in the plaintiff’s account was withdrawn by the plaintiff from the bank and the real estate was purchased on a date consistent with the withdrawal date, it cannot be said that the money withdrawn from the plaintiff’s account constitutes the beginning of evidence.
If there is no written evidence or “beginning of evidence”, it is possible to prove the belief contract with conclusive evidence such as confession (HMK art. 188) and oath (HMK art. 225 et al.). If the plaintiff is based on the evidence of the oath, the judge must remind the plaintiff of this right. (The Decision of the General Assembly of the Supreme Court of Appeals, dated 09.12.2015, numbered 2014/14-516, Basis, 2015/2838 is in this direction.)
Since it was understood that the plaintiff had also waived the evidence of the oath on which he clearly relied in the petition of the lawsuit, it was not considered correct to give a written decision, while the decision to reject the case that could not be proven was not right, and the judgment had to be overturned.