It is observed that the banks gave negative answers to the requests such as address and identity number requested by the judicial authorities with the writ. For example, the Bank’s ID number belonging to the debtor was requested from the bank by the Enforcement Directorate for the purpose of address search, the bank gave a negative response to this request, and the dispute became the subject of a lawsuit. As a result of the proceedings, the bank’s act of giving a negative response to the executive director’s warrant on the grounds of personal data was found unjustified.
Decision of Ankara 3rd Enforcement Law Court on the Subject dated 19.07.2022
At the end of the open trial of the Complaint (Executive Officer Treatment) case pending in our court, IT IS DECIDED:
COMPLAINT:
In summary, in the petition submitted by the complainant’s attorney to our court;
However, Ankara 6th Enforcement Directorate re-sent the warrant dated 13/07/2022 and requested that the TR Identity Number be sent to the file again in case it is on behalf of the debtor by querying the Iban number notified, and that it was sent by the Ankara 6th Enforcement Directorate dated 23/05/2022 and dated 13/ The warrants dated 07/2022 should be cancelled, since the enforcement authorities’ power to request information is limited to the presence of the debtor; Pursuant to the provisions of Article 73 of the Banking Law on customer confidentiality and exempted from the exceptions regarding the transfer of personal data in the KVKK No. 6698, the writ in question constitutes a violation of the law, and that the writ dated 13/07/2022, which was issued by the enforcement office and sent to the client bank, lacks any legal basis. Therefore, Ankara 6. He requested the cancellation of the warrants dated 23/05/2022 and dated 13/07/2022 issued by the Enforcement Directorate. In summary, in the reply petition submitted by the complainant’s attorney to our court; It is not possible to refrain from giving information on the grounds of the Banking Law, Enforcement offices take their authority from the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law, that the law fulfills its duty of enforced enforcement, that the State’s power of enforcement is related to the power of the State to protect the creditor against the debtor and to use force when necessary, at the point of forcible collection of the debt. When the law provision referenced in the banking law is examined, it is seen that many authorities are in the enforcement offices, that the Ankara 6th Enforcement Directorate requests the address information from the bank in order to make a notification to the debtor, but the bank provides a negative response.
DISCUSSION OF EVIDENCE AND JUSTIFICATION:
According to Articles 18/3 of the İİK and 320/1 of the HMK, it was appreciated that there was no need for the enforcement office to make a statement and to hold a hearing, and the file was examined.
The execution file of Ankara 6th Enforcement Directorate with the main number 2022/… has been examined.
The complaint is about whether it is necessary to cancel the warrants dated 23/05/2022 and 13/07/2022 sent to the complaining bank from the file of the Ankara 6th Enforcement Directorate with the file numbered 2022/….
The file of Ankara 6th Enforcement Directorate no 2022/… was summoned and examined. It was appreciated that there was no need to hold a hearing in accordance with Articles 18/3 of the İİK and 320/1 of the HMK, and the file was examined.
Pursuant to Article 73 of the Banking Law; “Board chairman and members, Agency personnel, Fund Board chairman and members and Fund personnel cannot disclose the secrets of banks and their subsidiaries, affiliates, jointly controlled partnerships and customers to anyone other than those authorized in accordance with this Law and special laws, and their own or others’ secrets. they cannot use it to their advantage. Persons and organizations from which the institution receives external support services and their employees are also subject to this provision. This obligation continues even after leaving office.”
When the entire scope of the file is evaluated together with the follow-up file; The above-mentioned restrictions in the law prevent the members of the banks and other officials from disclosing the secrets of the banks and their customers, which they have learned because of their titles, voluntarily and arbitrarily, and that the said article does not cover the forced execution, since there is no restriction affecting the enforced execution in the aforementioned article. Notice dated 2021, numbered 2021/497 and Decision numbered 2021/4842), a warrant to each of the relevant institutions and organizations in order to conduct an address search in order to ensure the notification of the payment order to the debtor by the executive directorate in the file no 2022/8827 of the Ankara 6th Enforcement Directorate. can be written,
PROVISION : As its justification is explained above;
1- DISCLAIMER OF THE COMPLAINT,
2- Since the fee is taken in advance, there is no room for it to be taken again,
3- LEAVING the litigation expenses incurred by the complainant during the trial on the COMPLAINT,
4- Since there is no court expense incurred by the complainant, there is no room for a judgment in this matter,
5- Considering that the complaint relates only to the treatment of civil servants, there is no room for ATTORNEY FEE APPRECIATED IN FAVOR OF THE COMPLAINT,
6- When the decision is finalized, HMK of the balance expense advance. RETURN to the complainant pursuant to Article 333,
About; In the absence of the parties, within 10 days from the date of notification of the reasoned decision, with a petition to our Court or to the Enforcement Law Court of the place where they are located or any other place, the court of appeal is open to the Ankara Regional Court of Justice, and if the appeal is not applied within the time limit, the judgment will be finalized. The decision was made as a result of the review. 23/11/2022
Conclusion
Although the bank has refrained from providing the information about the debtor to the Enforcement Directorate, citing Article 73 of the Banking Law, titled “Keeping Secrets”, the Enforcement Offices are legally authorized to conduct an address search and collect information about the debtor in order to make difficult purchases. For this reason, it is illegal for the bank to refrain from giving information about the debtor to the Enforcement Office and cannot be evaluated under the title of keeping secrets.