EXECUTION FILE NO:
APPLICANT / DEBTOR:
ATTORNEY:
DEFENDANT/CREDITOR:
ATTORNEY:
SUBJECT : Our objection regarding the follow-up.
DATE OF NOTIFICATION: The notification was received on the date of the lawsuit.
DESCRIPTIONS
1-) In the execution file, the information of which is written above, the defendant/creditor has initiated an enforcement proceeding against my client for bills of exchange, and the relevant payment order has been notified to the client on the above-mentioned date. For this reason, it is clear that our objection is within the legal time limit.
2-) My client is the first beneficiary of the bond under enforcement proceedings. It then appears that he endorsed the bond to the defendant and became a endorser. The defendant/creditor has not filed a non-payment protest against us or the drawer. Therefore, the endorser has lost its right to apply to our party, and now only has the right to turn to the drawer. As a matter of fact, Article 714 paragraph 3 of the Commercial Code
“(3) The protest for non-payment to be drawn due to a policy that includes the condition to be paid on a certain day or after a certain period of issuance or sighting, must be withdrawn within two business days following the payment day.”
It is stated that the withdrawal of the non-payment protest is mandatory. Again, the sanction of not withdrawing this protest is in Article 730 of the same law, titled “Release of the right to apply”:
“(1) Bearer;
a) Presenting the policy that must be paid when seen or after a certain period of time,
b) Arranging a protest of non-acceptance or non-payment,
c) If there is a record of “refundable without expense”, the policy is presented for payment,
If he expires, he loses his rights against the endorsers, the issuer and other debtors, with the exception of the acceptor.”
He clearly stated that he would lose his right to appeal to endorsers with his words. As we mentioned above, my client is an endorser in this enforcement proceeding and the defendant bearer neither the drawer nor us any protest, in the case law of the 12th Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Appeals dated 16.02.2016, 2016/617 Principle, 2016/3995 Decision no:
“The creditor bearer cannot follow the beneficiary and the endorser without making a protest under the aforementioned article conditions. In other words, the bearer loses the right to appeal against the beneficiary and endorser, since the issuer of the deed is not protested. 170/a-2 of the EBL. Pursuant to the article, it is obligatory to investigate ex officio whether the creditor has the right to follow-up pursuant to the foreign exchange law by the enforcement court.”
As it can be easily understood from his words, it is clear that the defendant does not have the right to appeal to my client, who is an endorser. Because, as we tried to explain, according to the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, if the non-payment protest is not withdrawn within the period, the right of application to persons other than the drawer and the avalist is lost.
3-) As a result; In our opinion, it has been determined that the creditor is not a creditor from my client, who appears to be the debtor in the enforcement proceedings subject to the case, and that he does not have the right to proceed in accordance with the foreign exchange law, and therefore, my client should be removed from the debtor status in the enforcement proceedings subject to the case.
LEGAL REASONS: Other legal regulations of the İİK, TTK, HMK
LEGAL EVIDENCE: Execution file with the above information, all kinds of evidence that can be submitted
DEMAND AND RESULT: As a result of the supply and reasons explained above
1-) First of all, the EXECUTION FOLLOW-UP in the execution file, the information of which is written above, is to be suspended, as a precaution,
2-) With the acceptance of our justified action, it is determined that the creditor does not have the right to pursue my client due to the execution proceeding based on the bill of exchange, the removal of my client’s indebtedness status, the cancellation of the payment order against my client in this respect,
3-) The litigation expenses and attorney’s fees are charged to the defendant,
I respectfully submit and request the decision on behalf of the proxy.
By clicking here, you can access our other article examples and petition examples.