14. Legal Department 2021/271 E. , 2021/2550 K .
“text of jurisprudence”
COURT : Court of First Instance
19.08.2014 at the end of the hearing, which was held by the plaintiff’s attorney in compliance with the petitions filed against the defendants on the days of 08.08.2017 in the combined case and the cancellation and registration of the title deed due to the preemption in the original case, cancellation of the title deed based on the promise of sale contract in the combined case and cancellation of the order of cancellation upon the registration request at the end of the hearing; active denial of the absence of antagonism of the original trial, combined from the direction of the case than a denial of the defendant … the timeout, a rejection of the principles given in terms of the other defendants for the plaintiff’s attorney requested by examination yargitayca provision 30/11/2020 blog, but apparently once it has been decided upon the adoption of the appeal petition, and within it resolved by examining the file all the paperwork:
K A R A R
The actual case is related to the cancellation and registration of the title deed arising from the right of preemption, the cancellation and registration of the title deed arising from the contract of sale promise of the case combined after the cancellation.
In the main case, the plaintiff’s attorney stated that the plaintiff is a stakeholder in 3 parcels on 349 island, that 1/3 of the shares belonging to the defendant … were sold to the defendant … on 28.10.2013 and requested the cancellation and registration of the title deed arising from the right to pre-purchase.
In the combined case; The defendants’ attorney argued for the dismissal of the case separately by objecting to the statute of limitations.
By the court, unopened considered to be the first decision of the case, the plaintiff of counsel on appeal dated 16.01.2017 2015/7295 principles and Decision No. 2015/277 our apartment with the sentence: “…by the plaintiff HMK 119/B deficiencies are fulfilled understood that because the court, a party formation by overcoming deficiencies regarding the establishment of the other party after it is completed by entering into the merits of the case in writing as to when a decision should be made towards the establishment of the provision reported, ” on the grounds that it was quashed.
In the aftermath of the destruction are combined in the case that the plaintiff plaintiff’s Attorney …’s real estate parcel No. 349 dated a stake in 04/05/2006 Island 2 a sales contract, with the promise of a contract with the promise of the stock 28/12/2006 dated sales … bought …the defendant’s status the shares of knowing tricks with a hand, then the registration on their behalf based on the sales contract and the deed by stating that provides cancel the registration request were found.
By the court, according to the warrant reversal, the trial is conducted in the second sentence of the trial, the denial decision given on appeal by the plaintiff by the counsel of the provision, with the announcement of our apartment; ”as for a concrete case, the court by the plaintiff and a preliminary agreement to sell 04825 date 04.05.2006 journal Journal Number Number Date 28.12.2006 17171 on the basis of the defendants …, …, … with the cancellation of the deed of the immovable Island 2 against No. 349 parcel on the merged file into being undecided about name registration unprecedented…” – shaped justification is corrupted.
The court decided to reject the original case due to the absence of active hostility by complying with the decision of annulment, and to reject the combined case on the merits from the other defendants due to the statute of limitations from the point of view of the defendant.
The decision was appealed by the plaintiff’s attorney.
1) According to the trial, the evidence collected and the entire file content, all the other appeals of the plaintiff’s attorney against the case in the main file, which are outside the scope of the following subparagraph in the case in the combined file, were not seen on the spot and had to be rejected.
2) The source of the Turkish Code of Obligations 29. real estate sales promise contracts, which are included in Article 237 of the Turkish Code of Obligations. article 706 of the Turkish Civil Code. and 89 of the Notarial Code. it is a type of contract that must be arranged ex officio in front of a notary in accordance with the provisions of the article, in other words, its validity is made conditional on the official form, it imposes a debt on both parties and provides personal rights. 716 of the Turkish Civil Code when the promised creditor fails to fulfill the performance of the seller who is burdened with the property transfer debt by the immovable sale promise contract. in accordance with the article, he may request the cancellation of the title deed and the fulfillment of the debt in the registration case.
146 of the Code of Obligations, since there is no special statute of limitations for cases arising from a promise to sell immovable property contract. in accordance with the provision of the article, the statute of limitations of ten years is applied, and this period begins to operate with the emergence of the possibility of performance of the contract. However, if the immovable property promised for sale has been delivered to the person who accepted the sales promise by contract or actually, that is, to the promised creditor, then the statute of limitations defense in lawsuits filed after the expiration of the ten-year statute of limitations is 2 of the Turkish Civil Code. since it is incompatible with the “Rule of acting honestly” contained in the article, it does not rest.
As for the concrete incident; The parties to the contract dated 04.05.2006 are the plaintiff and the defendant … and the contract has been arranged in accordance with the procedure. The plaintiff filed a claim for cancellation of the title deed and registration based on the sales promise agreement, the defendant … put forward the statute of limitations def, the court decided to dismiss the case on the grounds that the statute of limitations had expired.
An important problem is what will be the starting date of the statute of limitations in resolving the dispute. it is also accepted by the court that the ownership of the immovable property subject to the lawsuit was transferred to the plaintiff in accordance with the real estate sales promise agreement dated 04.05.2006 and that the plaintiff maintained his ownership without contention until the date of the lawsuit. As long as the possession continues, it is not mentioned that the statute of limitations has expired. In this case, it is not correct to decide to dismiss the case with a bet because the statute of limitations has expired.
Then, while a decision should have been made by the court by examining the merits of the work, it was not considered correct to make a decision in writing with an erroneous assessment, and the verdict had to be overturned for these reasons.
CONCLUSION: A unanimous decision was made on 07.04.2021 to reject all the appeals of the plaintiff’s attorney in the main case for the reasons described in paragraph 1 above, and other appeals in the combined case, to OVERTURN the judgment by accepting the appeals objections for the reasons described in paragraph 2, to refund the advance fee to the depositor, with the way to correct the decision being open within 15 days from the notification of the decision.
You can reach our other articles, sample decisions and petitions by clicking here.