14. Legal Department 2021/554 E. , 2021/1438 K .
“text of jurisprudence”
14. law office
COURT : Court of First Instance
14.10.2014 preemption by the plaintiffs against the defendant by Attorney given on the day the petition due to the cancellation of the deed and registration at the end of the trial, the result of the request; the absence of the circumstances of the case the plaintiffs and plaintiff separately provision given for rejection 12.12.2014 blog yargitayca examination by the attorney asked, but apparently once the petition of Appeal has been decided upon the adoption of time, and resolved it by examining all the papers in the file:
decision
The case is related to the cancellation of the title deed based on the right to advance and the registration request.
The plaintiffs’ attorney stated that the plaintiffs entered into a floor-for-floor construction contract with the defendant company, Karsiyaka 2. The Commercial Court of First Instance filed a lawsuit against the debtor company with the file numbered 2013/94 and decided to accept the case, Karsiyaka 3. To follow up with the Executive Directorate of 2013/12953 a numbered file they put semeresiz left pursuit, the defendant is a debtor in the case of a company Holdings stock transfer, noting that the savings made for the purpose of smuggling collusive transfer cancellation, if it does not, because the right of lien of the deed of cancellation of registration with the decision to be given to that requested.
The defendant’s attorney defended the dismissal of the case.
In terms of the preliminary request, the court decided to serialize the case and recorded it on a separate basis and decided to dismiss the case due to the absence of litigation conditions on the grounds that the sale price was not stored.
The verdict has been appealed by the plaintiff nobles and the plaintiffs’ attorney.
The right of advance is a right that gives the other stakeholders the authority to purchase that share first in the immovable properties subject to the provisions of shared ownership, if the share is sold to a third party. This right arises as soon as the shared ownership relationship is established and becomes available by selling the share to a third party.
With the use of the right of pre-emption, a Decommissioning relationship is established between the stakeholder using this Decommissioning right and the buyer, the scope and conditions of which are the same as the contract concluded between the seller and the defendant. The pre-payment fee consists of the sale price shown in the deed and the sum of the fees and expenses paid by the defendant.
In the preliminary payment case, the preliminary payment fee, which consists of the sum of the mandatory fees and expenses to be paid with the sale price of the share subject to the lawsuit, is determined by Article 734/2 of the Turkish Civil Code No. 4721. in accordance with the article, the plaintiff must be given a period of time to be stored within an appropriate time to be determined by the court before the verdict. It may also be decided by the court that this period given to the plaintiff is final. If the prescribed operation is not fulfilled within the definite period, the 94 of HMK No. 6100. in accordance with the article, the right of the party who does not perform the transaction during the transaction period is eliminated. However, in order for the provision of this article to be applied, the plaintiff must act in a manner that will delay the case.
On the other hand, the Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 has divided the trial of the first instance into stages. These stages are:
a) Mutual submission of petitions,
b)Preliminary examination,
c)Investigation,
d) Oral trial,
e)Judgment
it consists of five stages, including.
The purpose of the preliminary examination stage organized in the “Fourth Section of the Code of Civil Procedure” is to make the necessary preparations before proceeding to the investigation stage, thus ensuring that both the court and the parties proceed to the investigation stage with complete dominance over the case and free of the reasons that will cause the case to be prolonged (Pekcanıtez / Atalay /Özekes, p.375-376; Ermenek, Ibrahim: ”Preliminary examination according to the Code of Civil Procedure”, Journal of Inönü University Faculty of Law, C. 2, P. 1, Y. 2011, p. 145-146). Indeed, when we look at the regulations on the subject, 137 of the HMK No. 6100. in the article, the scope of the preliminary examination; 138. decisions to be made about the conditions of the case and the first objections on the file during the preliminary examination stage in the article; 139. invitation to a preliminary examination hearing in Article 140. a preliminary examination hearing, which is mandatory in the article, has been organized.
A closer look at the regulations; HMK No. 6100 scope of preliminary examination titled 137. article; preliminary examination will be carried out after mutual submission of petitions, 138. in considering the item, primarily in litigation of the case to be decided via a file on preliminary objections and the requirements of the preliminary objections about the conditions and, if necessary, the court before you make your decision on this issue during the preliminary hearing, the parties are able to listen, within the scope of the claims and defenses of the parties during the preliminary hearing of the dispute can specify exactly the issues that the parties present their evidence and the preparation process for the collection of evidence will do the required operations on the parties in that case you can save freely, it is stated that he will encourage them to peace or mediation and these issues will be recorded in the minutes. It is envisaged to perform procedures such as witness listening, document examination, expert opinion taking, discovery making and oath offering at the preliminary examination hearing, limited to the case conditions and initial objections.
Looking at the procedures to be carried out at the preliminary examination stage, it can be said that the preliminary examination is accepted as a prerequisite for an effective investigation (Ermenek, p. 146). As a matter of fact, it is regulated in Article 137/2 of the Civil Code that “it is impossible to proceed to an investigation without completing the preliminary examination and taking the necessary decisions, and a hearing day cannot be given for the investigation”. This arrangement is a regulation of a mandatory nature. In order to definitively prevent the continuation of old habits in the practice of unnecessary hearings, the legislator expressly prohibited the transition to the investigation stage and the determination of the hearing day for the investigation before the preliminary examination stage is completed and the decisions that should be taken at this stage are taken (Pekcanitez / Atalay/Özekes, p.375-376).
Reciprocal granting of the petition phase is completed after the first file and the first by examining these issues through the terms of a lawsuit objections made a decision to be positive or negative; file preliminary objections that cannot be decided on the basis of the decisions about the case with the conditions of, and other pre-preliminary hearing for the parties to be invited to a review process, 6100) HMK 137 and 140. according to their articles, after the necessary procedural actions have been taken at the preliminary examination hearing, it is necessary to proceed to the investigation hearing.
140 of HMK No. 6100. in accordance with the article, at the preliminary examination hearing; It is arranged that the parties should be given a definite period of 2 weeks to submit to the court the documents they have shown in their petitions, but have not yet submitted, or to make the necessary statement in order to bring the documents to be brought from another place.
HMK 147. in accordance with Article; “The parties are invited to the hearing for the investigation after the completion of the preliminary examination stage. In the invitation to be sent, the parties are informed that if they are not present in court without a valid apology on the specified day and time, the hearing will continue in their absence and they will not be able to object to the proceedings.”
On the other hand, HMK 114. Article; (1) The conditions of the case are as follows:
a) The existence of the right of jurisdiction of Turkish courts.
b) The admissibility of the judicial way.
c) The duty of the court.
ç) In cases where the authority is final, the court shall be found competent.
d) The parties have the capacity of the party and the case; in the case of legal representation, the representative has the necessary qualifications.
e) To have the authority to follow the case.
f) In cases pursued through a proxy, the proxy must have a power of attorney license for the case and have a duly issued power of attorney.
g) The fact that the expense advance that the plaintiff should have deposited has been deposited.
d) Fulfillment of the requirements of the decision on the provision of collateral.
h) The plaintiff has a legal interest in filing a lawsuit.
i) The fact that the same case has been opened before and is still not being heard.
i) The fact that the same case has not been definitively adjudicated before.
(2) The provisions regarding the case conditions contained in other laws are reserved. It contains the arrangement in the form.
In the concrete case; although the court decided to dismiss the case due to the absence of litigation conditions by giving the plaintiff’s attorney a deadline for storing the preliminary examination fee with the invitation minutes dated 14.10.2014, it is not correct to think that the investigation cannot be started without completing the preliminary examination and making the necessary decisions, and the incoming period, which should be given at the investigation stage, cannot be given at this stage. Again, Article 114 of the Code of Civil Procedure. considering the regulation in the article, it was also not correct to decide to dismiss the case due to the absence of the case condition due to the failure to deposit the preliminary fee, since it is not regulated as a condition of the case, since the preliminary fee is not stored. For these reasons, the decision had to be overturned.
Conclusion: for the reasons described above provision plaintiffs attorneys and plaintiffs appeal with the adoption of the corruption of Appeals, in return for the fees she tucks cash deposit, and the decision to open the way for the correction of the decision within 15 days of the receipt of the unanimous on 03/03/2021
You can reach our other articles, sample decisions and petitions by clicking here