Events
As a result of an investigation opened against the applicant in 2000 while he was working as a teacher, 94 of the Civil Servants Law No. 657. in accordance with Article 98 of the aforementioned Law, he was deemed to have withdrawn from the civil service due to absenteeism. in accordance with the article, the applicant’s official position has been terminated.
The applicant became a member of a political party in 2001 and held various positions in the party. In the meantime, while the party membership continued, the applicant’s dismissal from the civil service due to absenteeism was canceled by the courts of Decency in 2008 and the applicant returned to his teaching position in 2008. Due to the fact that the applicant was a member of a political party when he returned to his post, an investigation was opened by the Ministry of National Education in accordance with the provisions of Law No. 657 and he was dismissed from his post. As a result of the investigation, the applicant was dismissed from the civil service by the decision of the High Disciplinary Board of the Ministry of National Education.
The applicant filed a lawsuit requesting the cancellation of the relevant transaction; the administrative court decided to dismiss the case on the grounds that the transaction was in accordance with the law. The decision was approved by the Council of State chamber; the applicant’s request for correction of the decision was rejected by the same chamber and the decision was finalized.
Count
The applicant claimed that the decision to dismiss him from the civil service because he was a member of a political party violated his freedom of association.
The Court’s Assessment
The obligation of civil servants to be impartial also means the neutrality of the state, because the state can only fulfill its neutrality on the occasion of the performance of the duties of civil servants. In this context, it is understandable that the state imposes heavy burdens on civil servants in the provision of services and prescribes strict measures to prevent disruptions that may occur in these services.
68 Of the Constitution. the provision in the article stating that civil service and political party membership cannot be found at the same time is aimed at ensuring the functionality of an impartial public administration acting on the basis of the rule of law. According to the said rule, even the implication that the independent duties performed by a civil servant are connected with political demands may undermine the objectivity of the state. For this reason, it is regulated in Law No. 657 that civil servants cannot be members of a political party within the scope of their responsibilities of impartiality and loyalty to the state. 125 of the same Law. in the article, entering a political party is ruled as a punishment for dismissal from office.
There is no doubt that intervention in the form of termination of civil servants who are members of a political party is a convenient tool in terms of preserving the principle of neutrality and loyalty to the state. In addition, it cannot be said that the regulation provided for in the law is not necessary in the face of the mandatory provision of the Constitution. Therefore, it should be concluded by determining whether the intervention is proportionate.
The need is 125 of the Law No. 657. the wording of the article Deciphering the application of the courts of instance, it is understood that the coexistence of civil service and political party membership is not accepted. According to the regulation, the relevant authorities and the courts of instance examining the decisions of these authorities only look at whether people are members of a political party and do not make a further assessment. In this respect, Article 125 of the Law. with the realization of the condition for joining a political party contained in the article, the civil service ends and individuals face a severe material and moral consequence. When this issue is observed, it can be easily stated that the regulation is a very heavy interference with the freedom of association.
In the concrete case, the applicant is not a civil servant while he is a member of a political party. However, while his political party membership continued, he gained the title of civil servant. The applicant is a member of a legal party and the applicant’s peaceful non-action and discourse found in have taken a stance against the constitutional order, democratic social order of a breach of no claim has been made. After that, it was determined that the applicant was a member of a political party and a dismissal penalty was imposed on him, and the applicant was not given any voluntary option to terminate his membership in a political party.
In the examined application, it could not be stated that the applicant’s membership of a political party had unacceptable consequences. Then, with the provisions of the mentioned legislation, Article 68 of the Constitution. when the article was evaluated together, it was understood that lighter measures such as granting the applicant, who is a civil servant, a certain period of time to resign from political party membership, providing an opportunity for him to prefer one of the civil servants with political party membership, or suspending the civil servant could be taken Decisively. The direct dismissal of the applicant from the civil service just because he was a member of a political party was the most severe intervention that did not comply with the principle of last resort. Dec. 68 of the Constitution prohibits the coexistence of both civil service and political party membership. article 33 of the Constitution, which guarantees both freedom of association and freedom of association. the article can fully fulfill its functions only in the context of the development of pluralistic democracy and if they are interpreted with the axis of rights. Looking at the practice, it has been assessed that it is possible for the administration and the courts to interpret these constitutional provisions in favor of freedoms.
The Constitutional Court has ruled that the freedom of association has been violated on the grounds described.
You can access our other article examples and petition examples by clicking here