Anasayfa » Blog » Violation Of The Right To Respect For Private Life And Freedom Of Communication Due To The Registration Of Prisoners’ Letters In The Information System Of The National Judicial Network

Violation Of The Right To Respect For Private Life And Freedom Of Communication Due To The Registration Of Prisoners’ Letters In The Information System Of The National Judicial Network

Events

The applicant is currently under arrest in the penitentiary institution on the charge of membership in an armed terrorist organization.

The General Directorate of Prisons and detention houses dated 10/10/2016 Circular (Circular) with the detainees and convicts in penal institutions or authorities given to the counsel for the defence in a sealed envelope in the mail and faxes, all except for letters, faxes, and scanning of a petition by the National Judicial Network Computing System (UYAP) should be saved through penal institutions throughout the country that has been submitted to the Public Prosecution Office. The execution institutions have also started the application in accordance with the Circular content. The letters sent by the applicant and received by him were also recorded in UYAP within the scope of the aforementioned Circular.

The applicant applied to the execution judge with the request to terminate this practice and delete the records. The execution judge is responsible for the Execution of 68 of the Law No. 5275 on the Execution of Criminal and Security Measures. in paragraph (2) of the Article, he stated that this practice is not contrary to the Constitution, emphasizing that it is regulated that letters, faxes and telegrams sent by the convict and received by him will be supervised by the letter reading commission, and if there is no commission, the highest supervisor of the institution. The applicant’s objection to the above-mentioned decision was also rejected by the assize court.

Count

The applicant claimed that his right to respect for private life and freedom of communication were violated due to the fact that all the letters sent to him in the penitentiary institution where he was under arrest and which he wanted to send were recorded in the UYAP.

The Court’s Assessment

The practice of recording prisoners’ letters to the UYAP is based on Article 38 /A of the Criminal Procedure Code No. 5271 and Article 68 of the Law No. 5275. article 122 of the By-Law (By-Law) on the Management of Penitentiary Institutions and the Execution of Criminal and Security Measures. and 123. it is based on the Circular with its articles.

First of all, 68 of the Law No. 5275 on the restriction of correspondence between convicts and prisoners in penitentiary institutions by supervision. it has been seen that the regulation is regulated in the article and the Regulation based on the mentioned regulation and the details of the procedures and results of the audit are included. It is understood that when the aforementioned regulations are observed, the penitentiary institution is given the authority to inspect letters, in this context, letters that are not considered objectionable should be delivered or sent to the addressee, and those that are considered objectionable should be kept in the execution institution.

On the other hand, Article 38 / A of the Law No. 5271 also regulates that all kinds of data, information, documents and decisions related to criminal procedure can be processed, recorded and stored through UYAP. When both laws and the relevant legislation are evaluated together, it can be said that there is a legal regulation that allows the correspondence of prisoners to be recorded in the UYAP, as a rule, within the scope of the supervisory authority granted to the execution institution. However, the formal existence of laws on the restriction of fundamental rights and freedoms is not enough. The criterion of legality also requires a material content, and at this point the nature of the law becomes important.

In this case, the prisoners ‘ correspondence with the topics you want to keep private life private, which may contain information that will remain within the scope of personal data when the law that is given on the subject of the prisoner’s fundamental rights and freedoms be restricted should be able to determine the principles and basic fundamentals that should also be stressed. In this context, the law or legislation based on the relevant law is expected to determine the principles regarding the systematic recording of correspondence and the protection of personal data, in particular, the confidential information contained in the letter and its contents. However, prisoners ‘ correspondence, the duration of the eclipse, this correspondence of the data with third-party access content, use, disposal, and in relation to the issues of ensuring the confidentiality of the data of the respondents and against the arbitrariness of the authority must contain a clear and detailed rules to ensure we have enough security.

It has been assessed that the regulation in the concrete case allows the preservation of the prisoner’s correspondence, which is not objectionable, including personal information and unrelated to judicial processes, by recording it in the UYAP, resulting in a departure from the procedure determined by the legislation according to whether the letter is objectionable or not.

However, it should be underlined that all correspondence, regardless of whether it is objectionable or not, is systematically recorded in the UYAP without considering the differences between the application subject of the application and the characteristics of the crime subject to conviction or the status of the detainee and the convict in the context of criminal law. In addition, it has been understood that there is no clear regulation on how long the prisoner’s correspondence will be stored in the system, under what conditions it will be opened to third parties for access and use, with which authorities it can be shared by the execution institution, how to protect personal data and privacy, and there is uncertainty in practice in terms of these issues. In the context of these explanations, it was concluded that there was no legal basis for the intervention.

The Constitutional Court has decided that the right to respect for private life and the freedom of communication have been violated on the grounds described.

 

By clicking here, you can access our other article examples and petition examples.

 

 

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir