Anasayfa » Blog » If The Case For The Dissolution Of The Partnership Has Been Finalized, The Case For The Determination Of Innovation Cannot Be Opened

If The Case For The Dissolution Of The Partnership Has Been Finalized, The Case For The Determination Of Innovation Cannot Be Opened

8. Legal Department 2013/23561 E. , 2014/16474 K.

“text of jurisprudence”

COURT : Düzce 2. The Court Of First Instance
DATE : 27/10/2011
NUMBER : 2011/106-2011/244

O.. Finish.. with N.. Finish.. and the commons on the rejection of the case for the determination of property between them, Dec. 2. Although the Court of Cassation requested the examination of the judgment No. 106/244 issued on the day of 27.10.2011 from the Court of First Instance by the plaintiff’s attorney during the period; the file was examined and considered as necessary:

decision

The plaintiff’s attorney Düzce 2 in the case petition. With the case file numbered 2006/1754 and 2009/644, the Civil Court of Peace announced that the case for the elimination of the partnership in respect of 87 parcels had been opened, concluded and approved and finalized, and requested that it be decided to determine that the ownership of the one-storey house and two buildings located on the said parcel belongs to the proxy.
Defendant H.. S.. in the trial session dated 28.06.2011, he informed that the one-storey house and two buildings on parcel No. 87 were built by the plaintiff, but the real estate remained from his father and was transferred to us heirs.
Although the other defendants were notified of the lawsuit petition, they did not attend the trial sessions and did not respond.
By the court; “…the case of the elimination of the related partnership move opened, and determined to onanar the decision made that is not a question of expropriation, the request that is related to the identification of muhdesat belonging to the request, the need for legal protection in other ways, it is completely fixable if you want the benefit of the plaintiff to the identification of the legal relationship that is not legal.,..” upon the decision to dismiss the case on the grounds of justification, the verdict was appealed by the plaintiff’s attorney.
The case is related to the request made by whom the muhdesat on the immovable is made.
Although the court has decided to dismiss the case due to the absence of legal benefits, it is not possible to agree with this reasoning of the court.
Although it is not included in the HUMK, the “principle of legal benefit” was accepted and applied as a condition of the case in terms of the opening of the case in accordance with the practice of the Court of Cassation. When HMK No. 6100 was prepared, this principle of legal benefit was made a provision of the law, inspired by the practice. It is seen that the principle of “the plaintiff’s legal benefit in filing a lawsuit” is considered among the terms of the lawsuit in subparagraph 114/1-h of the Dec. In cases where the principle of legal benefit exists, it is not necessary to open a case in a court first, then to obtain authorization from this court in terms of compliance or to perform any work, as well as to put something into enforcement proceedings first, after certain stages, there is no need to open any case by obtaining authorization from the executive director. Otherwise, there will be a Decommissioning or restriction of the right to seek ways.
As a matter of fact, Dec. 36 of the Constitution entitled freedom of search for rights. in its article; It emphasizes that “Everyone has the right to a fair trial as a plaintiff or defendant in front of judicial authorities by using legitimate means and means”. It is essential to keep the ways of seeking rights open, and restricting or completely closing them cannot be left to the discretion of individuals, institutions and organizations. Dec. 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights. in the article; emphasis was placed on the freedom to seek Decency and the right to a fair trial. The decisions of the Constitutional Court and the decisions of the European Court of Human Rights are also in this direction.
90 of the Constitution on this issue. its substance is also impossible to ignore. 90/5 of the Constitution. according to the paragraph; “Duly entered into force International Treaties have the force of law. It is not possible to apply to the Constitutional Court with the claim of violation of the Constitution about them. International treaties on fundamental rights and freedoms duly put into effect with provisions different laws on the same subject of disputes that may arise due to the inclusion of the provisions of international treaties shall prevail,” clearly when you have different provisions on matters of fundamental rights and freedoms that may arise is known for the superiority of the provisions of international treaties. With this provision in question, the restriction or closure of the right to seek ways is referred to in Dec. 90 of the Constitution. it constitutes a violation of the article.
Apart from this, no one can force another to file a lawsuit in one way or another first, to follow up, or to act or lead in any way.
In this regard, it is not possible to limit the determination of the belonging of muhdesat to two or three reasons, as explained by the majority in its reasoning. Moreover, there is no legal basis for this restriction. The important thing is to keep the front of rights and freedoms open. This Decisively means limiting the freedom of individuals or institutions and organizations to seek rights. Therefore, it is impossible to agree with this opinion.
8. The Legal Department, with its decision dated 15.10.2007 and numbered 2007/4224 Decision on the Basis 2007/5537; “… the move the premises of the plaintiff is not a stakeholder, stakeholders and externally with an immovable portion of the common shares on buying from one of invalid qualified building made muhdesat involved in the case, when the plaintiff resides in the position of a third person, this is where there is a dispute about the record owners (stakeholders) in the case of the partnership between the elimination of opened through the sale of the partnership in case of a decision to eliminate the parcel is located on muhdesat move (ground) without hesitation with regard to where they will be sold together, according to this situation, the plaintiff (the owner of the external sales deed) has a legal benefit in determining the value of the house located on the immovable and to whom it belongs, and in this regard, the court has decided to reject the plaintiff’s request for the determination of muhdesat, and there is no hit …” The Local Court’s decision to RESIST was overturned with the decision of the HGK dated 11.03.2009 and numbered 2009/8-75 Esas 2009/116 on a broader basis.
As can be seen, 8. The Legal Department accepts that the plaintiff has a LEGAL BENEFIT in the case of determining that the muhdesat was created (made) by the plaintiff, who bought the title DEED with an invalid external sales contract and has nothing to do with the land registry registration, and the Supreme General Assembly of LAW emphasizes that the plaintiff has a legal benefit, and it is decided to overturn the decision to resist.
High Again 7. Law Office “ opened the case of the elimination of the partnership related move, the process of expropriation is not in any, in this regard the determination of the plaintiff’s legal muhdesat belonging to one of the benefits of the opening of the case that should not have to warrant the reversal cannot be considered and dismissed the case, and date of HGK 05.10.2012 2012/7-334 Main 2012/650; 28.03.2014 date and 2013/7-670 2014/423 Basis (related to the subject of this judgment was sued for muhtesat after the elimination of the partnership between the stakeholders of a case was opened. However, legal benefit is a condition of the case and is sought at the time the case is opened, and although this is the principle, the HGK has accepted that the plaintiff in such a situation has a legal benefit.) and 2007/7-830 Basis, 2007/801 dated 31.07.2007 (after the local court decision on the determination of muhdesat belonging to the case subject to this decision was overturned, a lawsuit was filed to Decommission the partnership between the stakeholders. The information shown in parentheses with the second decision of the HGK is valid in this decision.) It has not adopted the limited opinion of the Special Chamber, which has been accepted to have the legal benefit of the plaintiff with the decisions numbered in the decision, on the two grounds in the annulment order.
As it is understood from the context of the case file No. 87 square made subject to the elimination of the cause of the partnership subject to accept the decision of the Supreme Court was approved through the control of given about the file when it is located between the field are moved according to land registry records, although it is not in the nature of the information and documents on file in single and two storey house is dry from immovable property, where the owners of the parcels subject to the collective ownership numbered 87, located between the defendant H.. S..when the statement of the dated 28.06.2011 is also taken into account, it is necessary not to hesitate that the plaintiff has a legal interest in opening such a case. It is a fact that when the parcel No. 87, which is subject to joint ownership, is put up for sale, the one-storey house, which is in the state of its permanent (integral part), and two pieces of dryness will be put up for sale together. In such a case, there is no doubt that the plaintiff will also be deprived of the essence of the right and will be forced to file other lawsuits, the plaintiff is obliged to file such a lawsuit again in order to receive the money for a one-story house and two pieces of dryness from the sale money.
When all these explanations are taken into consideration, the decision to reject the request on the grounds that the plaintiff has no legal benefit may mean sacrificing the essence of the right to the form.
HMK’s 106/2. according to the subparagraph, it cannot be said that the plaintiff does not have a current benefit worthy of legal protection in filing such a lawsuit.
In the face of these concrete and legal facts, it is not correct to decide to dismiss the case due to the absence of legal benefits, while a positive or negative decision should be made about the plaintiff’s request by collecting the evidence of the parties in the direction of the claim and defense and bringing it to the file on the elimination of the partnership and evaluating it together.
With the acceptance of the appeals of the plaintiff’s attorney for the reasons described, the local court’s decision is Provisional 3 of the CCP No. 6100. article 428 of the HUMK No. 1086. in accordance with Article 388/4 of the HUMK by the parties to its deterioration. (HMK m.297 /ç) and in accordance with Articles 440 / I of the HUMK, it was unanimously decided on 19.09.2014 that a request for correction of the decision can be made against the announcement within 15 days from the notification of the Court of Cassation Chamber decision and that the advance fee of 24.30 TL will be returned to the appellant plaintiff upon request.

You can reach our other articles, sample decisions and petitions by clicking here

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir