Events
Applicant, H.B.Y. together with the named person, they opened a banner at the exit of a metro stop near the Presidential residence in Istanbul and an investigation / prosecution was carried out against them within the scope of a terrorist organization.T. and A.Finish. he was arrested by law enforcement officers on the grounds that he shouted slogans about the named people and continued to act despite the warnings and was taken into custody on the same day.
The Prosecutor General’s Office; with the request to arrest the applicant for membership in an armed terrorist organization and opposition to the Law on Meetings and Demonstration Marches No. 2911 11. The Magistrate referred him to the Criminal Judge (Judge); the judge decided to arrest the applicant for the alleged crimes.
The applicant appealed against the arrest decision, 12. The Criminal Magistrate has decided to reject the appeal definitively. The applicant’s request for release is also 2. The Magistrate refused the sentence. The objection to the said decision is 3. The Magistrate has flatly refused.
The Prosecutor General’s Office opened a public case against the applicant in the same place as the high criminal court with the request to punish him for membership in an armed terrorist organization, making propaganda for a terrorist organization and opposing the Law No. 2911. 29. At the end of the hearing, the Assize Court (Court) decided to release the applicant by applying a judicial control measure in the form of a ban on going abroad. As a result of the trial, the Court decided to acquit the applicant of the outstanding crimes and to lift the judicial control measure applied. The Prosecutor General’s Office has applied for a legal remedy against the acquittal decision issued in terms of the crime of opposition to Law No. 2911, and the applicant has appealed against the part of the provision aimed at the power of attorney fee.
Count
The applicant claimed that his right to personal freedom and security had been violated due to the illegality of the arrest.
The Court’s Assessment
When the investigation documents about the applicant are examined, it is seen that the charges that form the basis of the arrest measure are based on the actions of the applicant in the form of opening banners and shouting slogans, which are stated to have been carried out by the applicant. The investigating authorities claimed that these actions were carried out mainly in accordance with the orders and instructions of the organization in order to serve the purpose of the organization and to carry out its propaganda. In this context, the investigating authorities referred to the activities of formations linked to the terrorist organization and referred to the E. On the banner carried by the applicant.T. and A.Finish. performed by a person named in a hunger strike right from the search path that had become an activity that serves the objectives of the terrorist organization and the applicant is in the nature of actions to support these individuals could be considered owned with a statement which stated that the terrorist organization iltisakli social media account.
It is clear that hunger strikes and sit-ins, which can be considered one of the manifestations of freedom of expression under certain conditions, or actions such as shouting slogans, making press statements, opening banners made by third parties in support of these actions, should not be the subject of criminal charges in themselves. However, if there are facts that the execution of these actions is an activity related to terrorism, or if behaviors such as praising, legitimizing or encouraging the methods of a terrorist organization that involve algebra, violence and threats are displayed during the actions, it may be considered a crime to consider such activities.
In this context, the facts based by the investigating authorities that the applicant’s actions, which were the subject of a crime and formed the basis for the arrest measure, were carried out on the instructions of a terrorist organization and in accordance with the goals of this organization, are generally the defense and support of these actions on certain platforms that are considered to be connected with this organization. On the contrary, no concrete facts or determinations were included in the investigation documents regarding the fact that the applicant carried out these actions in an organizational relationship or that this was exhibited as an organizational attitude on the part of the applicant.
On the other hand, the applicant; E, who participated in the death fasting action of himself.T.nin is his aunt, these actions are his niece E.T.he stated that he did it with the purpose of supporting Dec, that he chose it as a way of seeking rights and that it did not have an organizational purpose. Therefore, it was understood that the investigating authorities could not show concrete facts that the applicant carried out the aforementioned actions that were the subject of the accusation on the instructions of the organization or that the applicant had a connection with the organization in question.
In this respect, according to the applicant’s defense and the scope of the file, it was concluded that the strong indication that a crime had been committed, which was necessary for arrest in the concrete incident, could not be sufficiently revealed.
The Constitutional Court has decided that the right to personal freedom and security has been violated on the grounds described.
By clicking here, you can access our other article examples and petition examples.
