Events
The applicant is a columnist in the local newspaper Yeni Marmara (newspaper). The applicant, on the other hand, is serving as the provincial chairman of a political party at the time of the incident. The applicant made the news titled “Awesome Caliper“ in the copies dated 16/3/2017 of the said newspaper; “What FETÖ has done in the past in Bursa, what is it” in the copies dated 22/3/2017 and 23/3/2017. In the news titled ”Awesome Conspiracy“, the client was mentioned as ”The lawyer of FETO’s Torun”.
Upon the mentioned news, the applicant filed a complaint against the applicant with the request that he be punished for the crime of defamation. Of the chief state prosecutor (Da) engaged in Criminal Court trial on indictment, the applicant in question is in the news because of a judicial statements 2.320 the crime of insult TL has decided exactly what to be punished with a penalty.
Count
The applicant claimed that freedom of expression and freedom of the press had been violated due to the fact that he had been punished for the crime of defamation because of the news he had made.
The Court’s Assessment
The applicant is not expected to act as a prosecutor proving the accuracy of a statement while fulfilling his obligation of proof. The research obligation mentioned here should not be understood in the sense of concrete reality, but as compliance with the way the event unfolded at the time of publication. It is sufficient for the applicant to reveal whether the news sources are reasonably reliable in terms of the allegations in question and whether he has made efforts in good faith to provide accurate and reliable information.
It is observed that the news items subject to the application as a whole are related to the client’s relations with public officials and clients who have had contact with the Fetullahist Terrorist Organization / Parallel State Organization (FETO/PDY) in the past. In this context, an investigation was conducted by the court of first instance to determine whether there was an investigation, a lawsuit or any complaint filed against the applicant related to FETO /PDY. Accordingly, the Chief Prosecutor’s Office has been informed that an investigation has been initiated against the applicant in terms of FETO/PDY membership and that the aforementioned investigation resulted in non-follow-up on 6/7/2017. Proceeding from this, the applicant stated that it could not be considered unusual for him to report on the same subject as a journalist in an environment where allegations of a similar nature about the applicant were seriously investigated by the Prosecutor General’s Office.
Although it is clear that the applicant reported on a matter that was the subject of an official investigation in the concrete incident, it is indisputable that the aforementioned situation will not automatically give the allegations contained in the news content a factual basis as a whole and automatically. In this context, it is necessary to examine the claims contained in the content rather than the subject of the news. In the aforementioned non-prosecution decision, it was observed that the investigation of the Prosecutor General’s Office was initiated after local press reports indicating that the client was associated with FETO / PDY were the subject of notifications, and accordingly, the findings that the client “had telephone contact with some suspects associated with FETO” were included. Apart from this, there has not been any determination that meets the claim that “the affairs of those who donated to FETO were closed from a judicial point of view, provided that a power of attorney was given to the client,” which is the main basis of the allegations, or that can be counted against the client. In this sense, although it can be said that the applicant based his claim to the client’s relations in the context of the subject at first glance, it is not possible to extend the aforementioned determination to serve as the basis for the “donation to FETO-power of attorney to the client” relationship.
While there is no doubt that politicians should show more tolerance to the news made about them than ordinary people, the client should not be expected to tolerate allegations that are made in such a way that they are perceived as real in front of the public, as in the concrete case, but that cannot be shown to go beyond rumors. According to the opinion of the Constitutional Court, the applicant made the news in question without adequately supporting his claim of factual attribution. Therefore, it was concluded that the interference with the freedoms of expression and the press of the applicant, who could not show that he was trying to act in a way that would provide accurate and reliable information, corresponded to a mandatory social need and did not exceed the margin of appreciation that the court of first instance had when balancing different interests.
It should also be evaluated whether the judicial fine imposed against the applicant is in a reasonable proportionality relationship with the purpose pursued. In this context, dominated by the degree against the applicant, the applicant’s criminal fines will put pressure on economic opportunities to reduce or eliminate the amount, but also -in cases like this, usually dominated the news in question amounts and with the weight of compared to the desired objective to be achieved without disproportionate were evaluated.
The Constitutional Court has decided that the freedoms of expression and the press have not been violated on the grounds described.
By clicking here, you can access our other article examples and petition examples.
