Anasayfa » Blog » Violation Of Freedom Of Expression Due To The Imposition Of A Penalty For Temporary Suspension From Work

Violation Of Freedom Of Expression Due To The Imposition Of A Penalty For Temporary Suspension From Work

Events

Gestational diabetes because of his comments about the applicant at various dates on TV shows about ”expertise on a subject to make a medical assessment of non-harm to public health with scientific explanations, descriptions, making ads with colleagues make comments zemmedici, a disciplinary investigation was initiated with the allegations of ”using an unethical discussion method with physicians who think differently from him in a dispute about a medical issue” and the applicant was temporarily suspended from the profession for fifteen days by the decision of the Honorary Board of the Medical Chamber. The decision was approved by the High Honorary Board of the Turkish Medical Association (TTB). The case filed by the applicant with the request to cancel the said decision was rejected by the Administrative Court, and the request for appeal was rejected by the Regional Administrative Court.

Count

The applicant claimed that his freedom of expression had been violated due to the imposition of a sentence of temporary suspension from the profession for fifteen days due to statements with medical content that he had made on different dates on television programs.

The Court’s Assessment

The applicant was punished on the grounds that he made a statement in a field in which he was not an expert. As far as it is understood, the TTB did not consider it appropriate for the applicant to explain his thoughts in an area where he did not have a certificate of expertise. Undoubtedly, the introduction of the requirement to prove one’s expertise in order to make a statement of thought, even in a field that is scientifically qualified, restricts freedom of expression to a degree that makes it meaningless. Moreover, the applicant is a cardiology and internal medicine specialist, as well as one of the well-known academicians and scientists of Turkey in general.

From her point of view, the applicant explained the opinion that the oral glucose diagnostic test (OGTT) applied harmed the mother and child in a language that everyone could understand. Even if it is accepted that some of the applicant’s statements are critical of his colleagues or even exaggerated, it should not be the duty of the judicial authorities to replace a scientist and determine what form of expression will be used in a particular case. According to the assessment of the Constitutional Court, the applicant mainly targeted the applied method.

He wrote many books and television programs attended by the internet and social media sharing while the technical explanation from the applicant’s views gained great recognition in advertising to the point temellendirmey to be accepted as more of his books, beyond the ban on advertising of Physicians indirectly means shrinking the field of freedom of expression with the desired goal.

It has been accepted that the “television and written press” is not an appropriate environment in which the applicant does not make his statements “in a scientific environment and with scientific data”. The task of the courts is not to explain what terms such as “scientific environment” or “scientific data” mean. A well-known scientist and scholar in the medical field choose based on preference of the applicant’s own research topics, relevant and necessary resources to reach the data obtained according to the method adopted by scientific study, evaluation, conclusions, they need to appropriate environments and speaking freely with the community and the academic community to participate and share in description of typing is the most basic right.

Of course, it cannot be said that everything that scientists and academics say is absolutely true. However, it is an agreed fact that different, alternative views from each other create the possibility of thinking more accurately for everyone. Therefore, it is vitally important for individuals, society and the country that the applicant can oppose even the strongest opinions, even on an issue that is considered very critical and sensitive, such as maternal and child health.

As a matter of fact, the threat posed by the applicant’s statements to the health of the mother and child has not been concretely set out in the decisions of the courts of instance. Considering all the circumstances of the application, the applicant was temporarily suspended from the profession for fifteen days with the imposition of a severe disciplinary penalty, such as Article 26 of the Constitution. it has been concluded that the interference with the freedom of expression, which is protected in the article, does not correspond to a more pressing social need, nor is it proportionate.

The Constitutional Court has ruled that the freedom of expression has been violated on the grounds described.

By clicking here, you can access our other article examples and petition examples.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir