Events
To the Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office (Chief Prosecutor’s Office) “Petty Officer E., who is in charge of the Hadımköy Barracks Command.B. he is committing a crime against the state. I believe he released information about operations that should have been kept secret over the phone.” upon making a written notification in the form of E. By the Attorney General’s Office.B. about 328 of the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237. within the scope of the article, an investigation was initiated for the crime of political and military espionage.
Within the scope of the investigation, it was decided to determine the communication of the named person and their phones were tapped by the judge’s decision. It was determined that this person had made a large number of telephone conversations with the applicant and these conversations were recorded. After that, it was decided to detect and record the communication from the applicant’s point of view. The applicant was taken into custody in accordance with the listening recordings. The Prosecutor General’s Office is charged with the crime of disclosing information that should remain confidential regarding the security and political benefits of the state (329 of Law No. 5237. item) with the request to arrest the magistrates ‘ bench were shipped to the applicant was arrested.
About the applicant to disclose information relating to the security and political interests of the state demand a public trial for the crime to be punished opened. Dec Criminal Court in the decision of accepting the indictment output abroad the applicant has decided to release the Prohibition of judicial control in the form of the condition. Based on this decision by the US Attorney’s office about the applicant to provide information regarding the security of the State (Law No. 5237 327. the substance of an indictment for the crime are also organised. The indictment was accepted by the Court and it was decided to combine the case with the ongoing case.
The applicant is prohibited by the court’s initial actions were evaluated to provide information fall within the scope of a crime, and the crime is given for 1 years, 1 months, 10 days imprisonment has decided to postpone. It was assessed that the applicant’s second act fell within the scope of the crime of disclosing prohibited information and it was decided to punish him with a prison sentence of 2 years and 6 months for this crime.
Count
The applicant claimed that the right to personal freedom and security, as well as the freedoms of expression and the press, had been violated due to the arrest measure applied against him.
The Court’s Assessment
1. In Terms of the Alleged Violation of the Right to Personal Freedom and Security
In the concrete case, the applicant was arrested on the charge of disclosing confidential information related to the security and political benefits of the state; he was not arrested on the charge of providing this confidential information. Jul.
According to the Supreme Court, it is seen that state secrets are divided into three in general terms in the legislation. These are “information and documents that are essentially state secrets”, “information and documents prohibited by the competent authorities from disclosure” and “Information and documents kept secret by the administrative institutions of the state”.
According to the Supreme Court, 327 of the Law No. 5237. the word “Jul” mentioned in the article should be understood as making a voluntary, conscious and executive effort, resorting to means or reaching intermediaries in this regard, in any way, except for the accidental learning of information that should remain confidential. There is no need to disclose this information in order for this crime to occur. Jul-tification means learning the information in these documents without requiring the receipt of the documents. The crime is completed by providing information that is a secret.Jul. Dec Jul There is no difference between the supply of information directly from the source or from the transferor.
In terms of the crime of disclosing confidential information, the applicant’s E.B. it has been suggested that he compiled the confidential information he obtained from the named person and published it on the ODA TV website. E. By the investigating authorities.B.s Soldier, because it is obtained in a variety of ways and the security of the state, the political benefits in terms of internal or external nature of confidential information quoted applicant, the applicant is also a journalist because journalism across legal boundaries defined for this information under the name of ” freedom of the press has been suggested to explain to the public. In this context, six articles of the applicant were included in the indictment. However, only two of these articles were associated with information stated to be confidential.
The information disclosed within the scope of the applicant’s article, which supports the claim that he disclosed confidential information, relates to who was the commander to be sent to Libya. In the context of the specific circumstances of the concrete incident, it cannot be said that the disclosure of information about who is the commander to be sent to Libya during a period of hot conflicts is not capable of causing a potential danger to national security and the right to life of the commander whose name has been announced.
There are written explanations of the Ministry of National Defense, as the competent administrative authority, regarding the issues mentioned in the content of some of the telephone conversations between the applicant and the aforementioned soldier. Dec. Accordingly, it was stated that correspondence and reports were available in military sources regarding a significant part of the issues that the applicant asked the non-commissioned officer about and the information that this person gave to the applicant, and most of them were of a confidential nature.
Since the mentioned information is related to the operations of the Turkish security forces operating in Syria and Libya, it is possible to consider it as information that should remain confidential in terms of the nature of the security of the state or its internal or external political benefits. The applicant, who received this information, which is of critical importance for national security, is an experienced journalist who constantly writes about the Turkish Armed Forces; Jul is in a position to know that this information will have the quality of confidentiality and that the criminal provisions of Law No. 5237 will be applied in these matters if provided or disclosed. Information sharing is not a time, moreover, it is understood that this information can score in the period of conflict. This information is coincidentally the applicant is not in a conscious way to learn is in constant contact with the relevant Co for that information, and it is observed that asked questions to get to know this person more.
In the concrete case, issues such as operation routes are directly related to national security, and the names of the units are directly related to the life rights of the members of that unit. Even if this information has not been disclosed, the possession of this information by people other than those who need to know it may pose irreparable risks in terms of national security and the rights of others. In this context, the provision of the information mentioned by unauthorized persons carries the danger of causing irreparable harm to the interests of the country. Jul. The fact that the applicant did not act illegally such as theft, threats, blackmail at the point of obtaining information is not of decisive importance in assessing whether he complied with his duties and responsibilities in terms of his journalistic profession – in the circumstances of the concrete incident. Jul.
On the other hand, the fact that some of this information has been reported in other press organs does not have a decisive effect on the situation. Because the applicant does not transfer the information contained in other press organs and – even if it is assumed that this information has been published – confirms the accuracy of the information mentioned firsthand. In addition, it seems that a significant part of this information has not been made public before or has not become known to everyone.
As a result, it cannot be said that the assessments made by the investigative authorities and the judicial bodies that decided to arrest the applicant in the concrete case that there are strong signs of a crime in terms of the crime of providing information that should remain confidential in terms of the security of the state or its internal or external political benefits are unfounded Jul
Concrete cases in magistrates ‘ applicant’s arrest when he decided to Hakimligince; because the investigation continues to be a complete collection of evidence, the evidence in the case of the applicant’s release to have the possibility to influence the action to be taken in case of occurrence of the amount of the penalty constant is taken into account, when possible, to escape suspicion, the existence of judicial control measures won’t be enough alone was unbearable.
In addition, the magnitude of the danger posed to national security by the information provided by the applicant is incomparably greater than the interest arising from learning about them and sharing them with the public. Jul. When it comes to an action of this nature, national security outweighs the values protected by the freedom of the press. Considering the features of a concrete case, the magistrates ‘ bench sanctions for the offence of the weight of regard to the nature of the job applied for the arrest of the applicant about the application of moderate and judicial control measures would be inadequate lead us to conclude that it’s not arbitrary and baseless.
The Constitutional Court has decided that the right to personal freedom and security has not been violated on the grounds described.
2. In Terms of Alleged Violation of the Freedoms of Expression and the Press
In a concrete case that the applicant’s arrest was not legal claim is examined, the applicant may have committed a crime credible evidence to suspect that exists because of an arrest in the case and also we can say that it was concluded that the arrest in moderation. In this context, when you are considering evaluations of the applicants within the scope of expression and press freedom because of the actions of the only remaining exposed to the investigation he was arrested and that makes it necessary to reach a different conclusion in terms of the claim that there is a situation.
The Constitutional Court has decided that the freedoms of expression and the press have not been violated on the grounds described.
By clicking here, you can access our other article examples and petition examples.