Supreme Court 2. Criminal Department 2021/767 E., 2021/8659 K. “text of jurisprudence”
Refusal and Hesitation of the Judge
Code of Criminal Procedure 22-30. Material
Convicted of theft and violation of the immunity of housing …’s, 142/2-h, 143, 35, 116/4 and 62 of the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237. denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. The decision of the Criminal Court of First Instance dated 31.01.2019 and numbered 2018/121 basis, 2019/87 was issued by Antalya Regional Court of Justice 7. Following the finalization of the decision of the Criminal Chamber dated 18.04.2019 and numbered 2019/608 on the merits, 2019/1031 on the rejection of the appeal application on the merits, Denizli 1 on the rejection of the request for renewal of the trial made by the convict. Denizli 5th Criminal Court of First Instance’s authority on the rejection of the objection made against the additional decision dated 15.06.2020 and numbered 2018/121 October, 2019/87. Based on the request to overturn the law No. 17256-2020 dated 07.12.2020 and numbered 17256-2020 issued by the Ministry of High Justice against the decision of the High Criminal Court dated 02.07.2020 and numbered 2020/522 amended, the case file was read by sending it to our office on behalf of the Chief Public Prosecutor of the Supreme Court of Appeals dated 07.01.2021 and numbered 2020/112250 .
In the name of the communiqué that wants to disrupt the benefit of the law;
The accused for the crimes of theft and violation of the immunity of housing …’s, 142/2-h, 143, 35, 116/4 and 62 of the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237. denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. Denizli 1. The decision of the Criminal Court of First Instance dated 31.01.2019 and numbered 2018/121 basis, 2019/87 was issued by Antalya Regional Court of Justice 7. Following the finalization of the decision of the Criminal Chamber dated 18.04.2019 and numbered 2019/608 on the merits, 2019/1031 on the rejection of the appeal application on the merits, Denizli 1 on the rejection of the request for renewal of the trial made by the defendant. Denizli 5th Criminal Court of First Instance’s authority on the rejection of the objection made against the additional decision dated 15.06.2020 and numbered 2018/121 October, 2019/87. The file covering the decision of the Assize Court dated 02.07.2020 and numbered 2020/522 amended was examined. CMK No. 5271. nun 23/3. 318/1 of the same Law with the regulation in the article “In case of renewal of the trial, the judge who served in the previous trial cannot take part in the same job”. article “The request for renewal of the trial is submitted to the court that made the decision. This court decides whether the claim is worth the acceptance of” shaped the regulations in the face of the judge who made the first decision have formed opinions about the case, the first sentence of the opinion, clear re-trial phase or to take to the stage earlier in the decision of whether it is worth accepting the request under the influence of the belief and opinion that can remain, therefore, as an extension of the right to a fair trial, the event is completely foreign to a different judge must review the request for a retrial for the reason that, in the concrete case, since there was no hit in the decision to reject the objection in writing instead of accepting it in this direction, without taking into account that the Judge Necmettin Öter, who took part in the first trial, also took part in the decision on the rejection of the request for renewal of the trial, CMK No. 5271 No. 309. the need to overturn the said decision in accordance with the article has been notified based on the request to overturn it in the interest of the law.
has been considered:
The incident that needs to be resolved in the face of a request to overturn in the interest of the law, when there are requests to renew the trial, is related to determining whether the court that made the finalized decision on the request should make a decision on the valency of acceptance, whether there is a legal obstacle in this matter. In the CMK on the subject; Cases where the judge cannot look at the case 22. it is counted in the article. 23, titled the judge who will not be able to attend the trial. article “(1) A judge participating in a decision or decision may not participate in a decision or decision to be made by a high-ranking court regarding this decision. (2) A judge who has served in the investigation phase in the same job cannot serve in the prosecution phase. (3) In case of renewal of the trial, the judge who served in the previous trial may not serve in the same job. “. 23. article 3. in the justification regarding the paragraph; “In the event of a request to renew the trial, it has been added to the third paragraph that the judge who served in the previous trial will not be able to serve in the same job. Thus, the judge, who had previously stated his opinion on the same dispute, was prevented from serving in the process of renewing the trial later, and the judge’s impartiality was also sought to be ensured in this aspect, and 23. it has been accepted as matter.” it has been said. CMK 30. article; “(1) When a judge withdraws based on reasons requiring his prohibition, the authority appoints another judge or court to handle the case. (2) When a judge hesitates, citing reasons that may cast doubt on his impartiality, the authority decides whether it is appropriate to hesitate. If the reservation is found appropriate, another judge or court is assigned to handle the case. (3) The provision of Article 29 shall apply to the works performed in cases where delay is found to be objectionable.” CMK 318/1 on the subject. paragraph; “(1) The request for renewal of the trial is submitted to the court that made the decision. This court decides whether the claim is worthy of acceptance.” it is in the form of. In the face of these regulations; in the event of a request to renew the trial, the judge who served in the previous trial subject to the request will not be able to serve in the same job as CMK 318/1. in accordance with the paragraph, the decision on whether the request to be submitted to the court that made the decision is also worthy of acceptance and subsequent actions cannot be made by the judges who served in the previous trial, nor can they take part in the panel. The fact that there is a regulation in the section of paragraph 23/3 of the CMK entitled “The Judge’s Inability to Look at the Case and his Refusal” in the CMK is the 30th amendment of the CMK. CMK 22 in the face of the regulation of the subject of “Judge’s hesitation and examination authority” in the article. as in the cases to be determined by examining the form of population records such as marriage bond, blood-kinship bond listed in the article, 23/3. in case of prohibition arising from the paragraph, if the judge who received the request is the judge who made the decision or if he is in the committee, he must ensure the process by submitting the file to the authority in accordance with the procedure set out in the “Fifth Section” of the CMK by making a “decision of abstention” stating this issue in accordance with Article 30/1 of the CMK. The fact that it is accepted as a state of prohibition and is regulated in the “Fifth Section” of the CMK requires the resolution of the order with the procedural decision in this section. In this context, the decision on whether the request for renewal of the trial is worth accepting should be made by the same court, but with a panel to be formed by judges other than the judge, the president and the members who made the original decision. The judge who made the previous decision have formed opinions about the case, the first sentence of the opinion, clear, re-trial phase or to take to the stage earlier in the decision of whether it is worth accepting the request that can be influenced by the opinion and the opinion, therefore, as an extension of the right to a fair trial, the event is completely foreign to a different delegation that included judge/a judge will review the request for a retrial will be accurate. In the face of the above determinations, acceptance and evaluations; In the concrete case; due to the fact that the judge who issued the sentence of conviction subject to the renewal request is the judge who decided to reject the request for renewal of the trial, Denizli 5. Since the Assize Court should have decided to accept the objection in accordance with the provisions of the above-mentioned law, but decided to reject it in writing, the request to overturn it in the interest of the law is considered in place (DENIZLI) 5. 309 of the CMK No. 5271 of the decision dated 02.07.2020 and numbered 2020/522 Amended by the Assize Court. article 3. in accordance with paragraph 4 of the same article. in accordance with subparagraph a of paragraph merciince fulfillment at the scene of the next operation, the file will be sent to the court to be sent to the public prosecutor of the Supreme Court, on 20.04.2021 our members… and Circle …’s the same judge review the valence votes against the idea of acceptance, and it was decided by majority of votes.
You can reach our other articles, sample decisions and petitions by clicking here