Events
The applicant, a foreign national, applied to the Ministry of Internal Affairs (Administration) in order to obtain Turkish citizenship. Subsequently, due to the fact that he took over the transfer of the apartment, the title deed of which belonged to another person, a residence permit was issued to him for the purpose of acquiring property. In the Investigation Form prepared by the Provincial Police Department upon the applicant’s request to naturalize, it was emphasized that his life was not in accordance with Turkish customs and traditions. In addition, the applicant’s request to be granted Turkish citizenship was rejected by the Administration on the grounds that he did not meet the condition of having good morals contained in the Turkish Citizenship Law No. 5901. The lawsuit filed by the applicant requesting the cancellation of the said transaction was rejected by the Administrative Court, and the application for appeal was rejected by the Regional Administrative Court.
Count
The applicant claimed that his right to respect for private life had been violated due to the rejection of his request for naturalization on the grounds that he did not meet the requirement of having good morals.
The Court’s Assessment
In the Law No. 5901, it is stated that foreigners can acquire Turkish citizenship by decision of the competent authority if they meet certain conditions, and having good Decency is considered among the mentioned conditions. In the justification of the Law, it is stated that the requirement to seek this requirement is stated that the applicant, who wants to become a Turkish citizen, does not engage in behavior contrary to Turkish customs and traditions and social life.
It can be said that the requirement of having good morals sought in the legislation for naturalization has an abstract content, therefore, whether this requirement is met or not should be revealed with concrete data specific to the applicant. Based on this, decision-makers are expected to explain the disadvantages that will occur in the context of public order with adequate and relevant justification in case of naturalization according to the characteristics of the concrete event, taking into account the diversity in lifestyles that are the result of changes and developments in the social structure over time.
In the case filed with the request to cancel the transaction, the Administrative Court included determinations on the outcome of the investigation conducted against the applicant and stressed that the fact that the applicant has been in a relationship with a married person who is a Turkish citizen for 13 years is fixed. The Administrative Court concluded that the applicant’s extramarital union was damaging to the family institution under constitutional protection, contrary to the national and spiritual values of Turkish society, and that the conditions for obtaining Turkish citizenship were not met due to the fact that this situation could not be welcomed by society, and it was decided to dismiss the case by concluding that the condition of having good morals was not met. The Regional Administrative Court also rejected the application for appeal on the grounds that there was no reason requiring the lifting of the decision in question.
The reason given by the court of first instance that the applicant does not meet the requirement of having good morals is specific to the fact that the applicant has been in a relationship with a married person who is a Turkish citizen for 13 years. However, the applicant for a long time, do activities that disrupt public order will remain in Turkey legally and in this process of naturalisation after evaluating whether the conditions that are required for the discussion that is occurring in the public interest is critical to the establishment of a fair balance between the interests of the person. It has been observed that no assessment has been made on these issues and that no research has been conducted by the court of instance in this direction regarding whether the applicant meets the condition of having good morals.
Accordingly, the applicant’s Law No. 5901 in a concrete case together outside of marriage, which is located at the requirement of having good morals did not provide the rationale for that action when citizenship was denied, resulting in justification of the right to respect for private life does not contain a relevant and adequate intervention and, in this context, it was inferred that does not comply with the requirements of the Democratic social order.
The Constitutional Court has decided that the right to respect for private life has been violated on the grounds described.
By clicking here, you can access our other article examples and petition examples.