The Contested Rule
In the rules subject to objection; It is stipulated that a cancellation lawsuit cannot be filed against the warnings and partial continuation of service penalties given to officers, non-commissioned officers, specialist privates and contracted privates.
Grounds for Application
Summary of the application decision; legislation the contracting officer and field a certain number of disciplinary action by the employer of termination of the contract before the end of the contract period stipulated, the contract is able to be opened a case against the process of the dissolution of this part of the processing underlying the case of disciplinary action against the lawsuit filed in a legal termination of the contract because it could not benefit the process could not be achieved, hence it is concerned by the consequences of disciplinary action that can go until the termination of the agreement, to be left outside the scope of judicial review of state law for the principle of, it was Decried that the rules are contrary to the Constitution by stating that they are incompatible with the principles regarding the freedom to seek rights, the administration’s actions cannot be excluded from judicial control and the judicial avenue cannot be closed against disciplinary penalties.
The Court’s Assessment
36 Of the Constitution. although no reason for limitation is provided for the freedom to seek rights in the article, it is accepted that the rights for which no special reason for limitation is provided also have some limitations arising from the nature of that right. Dec. On the other hand, the rights and freedoms contained in other articles of the Constitution and the duties imposed on the state may constitute limits to rights and freedoms for which no special reason for restriction has been shown.
129 Of the Constitution. in the third and fourth paragraphs of the article, “Disciplinary decisions cannot be excluded from judicial supervision.
The provisions concerning members of the Armed Forces and judges and prosecutors are reserved.” the provisions are in place.
According to the first version of the article containing the Rules, “In accordance with Article 129 of the Constitution, it is possible to exclude disciplinary punishments against members of the Armed Forces from judicial review. In this direction, disciplinary penalties against members of the Armed Forces have been excluded from judicial review to date. In part, the law provides for the possibility of opening severe disciplinary penalties to judicial review. Considering such issues as the presence of the Turkish Armed Forces, the importance of the disciplinary facility, the nature of indiscipline and disciplinary punishments, the system of opening the judicial path to all disciplinary punishments was not preferred. Because it is assessed that such a system may cause serious harm to the discipline,” on the grounds that the rules are based on Article 129 of the Constitution. according to the discretion granted to the legislator in the article, it is understood that it is envisaged for the purpose of establishing discipline from the point of view of the Turkish Armed Forces (TAF) and has a legitimate purpose in the constitutional sense.
In this context, the rules should be examined in terms of compliance with the principle of proportionality. Considering that the effectiveness of such disciplinary penalties will be increased by closing the judicial avenue against penalties for warning and partial service attendance, it cannot be said that the rules are not favorable and necessary in terms of achieving the goal of ensuring discipline in the TAF.
On the other hand, making a habit of engaging in attitudes and behaviors that disrupt discipline or not improving despite the disciplinary penalties they receive are considered to be indisciplines that require the punishment of separation from the TAF. In terms of officers and NCOs, except for contracted officers and NCOs, this situation is accepted as a reason for separation from the TAF when the disciplinary penalties taken within certain periods of time reach a certain score. In terms of the contracted private and private, a total of eight times or more disciplinary penalties from at least two disciplinary supervisors in the last year may be the reason for termination of the contract before the end of its term.
In this case, the penalties of warning and partial continuation of service, the judicial path of which is closed, may lead to the departure of these military personnel from the Turkish Armed Forces or the termination of their contracts. The process of separation or termination of the contract from the Turkish Armed Forces, although there is a lawsuit against this process, which forms the basis of the excitation, and service-part of the judiciary on a term basis without appeal against the penalty and appeal process because the path need to be closed after the final question in disciplinary action subject to judicial review because it was not the mainstay of these operations-based control of the process from the Turkish Armed Forces becomes the shape of judicial separation or termination of the contract. In other words, due to the fact that the acts subject to warning and partial continuation of service penalties are not subject to judicial review of whether they require disciplinary punishment, the judicial review conducted in cases filed against separation from the TAF or termination of the contract loses its effectiveness. In this respect, the rules impose an excessive burden on military personnel and Dec Deconstruct the fair balance that should be observed between the public interest in the form of the establishment of discipline and the freedom to seek rights.
The Constitutional Court has decided that the rules are contrary to the Constitution on the grounds explained and that they should be canceled.
By clicking here, you can access our other article examples and petition examples.