Anasayfa » Blog » Violation Of The Right To Respect For Private Life Due To The Rejection Of The Lawsuit Filed With The Request To Cancel The Decision Made For The Hydroelectric Power Plant Project

Violation Of The Right To Respect For Private Life Due To The Rejection Of The Lawsuit Filed With The Request To Cancel The Decision Made For The Hydroelectric Power Plant Project

Events

Energy An environmental impact assessment (EIA) of the regulator and hydroelectric power plant (HEPP) project has been requested by a company engaged in electricity generation from the Ministry of Environment and Urbanization (Administration) and an EIA positive decision has been given to the project by the Administration.

The applicant filed a lawsuit in the administrative court requesting the cancellation of the provisional acceptance offer document, the Provisional Acceptance Minutes and some administrative procedures related to the project in question with the positive decision of the EIA for the project in question. The applicant, who claimed that the information provided in the EIA report did not reflect the truth, claimed that the positive decision of the EIA on the project in question eliminated environmental rights. The Administrative Court decided to reject the case from the point of view of the request for cancellation of the temporary acceptance offer document and the Temporary Acceptance Minutes with the positive decision of the EIA, and to reject the case without examination on the grounds that the aforementioned procedures are not final and necessary to be carried out from the point of view of the request to decide on the cancellation of other administrative actions. The applicant filed an appeal against this decision. The Council of State decided to approve the administrative court decision and the aforementioned decision by rejecting the request for appeal on the grounds that the decision and the grounds on which it is based are in accordance with the law and procedure, and there is no reason to overturn it.

Count

The applicant stated that a commitment had been made for the project that was technically impossible to fulfill, and that the water that was pledged to be left in the creek bed would not be provided due to the warehouse built above the project was not included in the expert’s report. In addition, the applicant stated that the pond planned to be established was not mentioned in the EIA report and that this issue was not taken into account by the courts of instance. As a result, the applicant, who stated that a holistic environmental assessment had not been put forward due to incomplete judgment, claimed that his right to respect for private life had been violated.

The Court’s Assessment

An EIA for investments and development and economic development without destroying the environment without polluting the nature of activities and the implementation used in the decision-making process influencing, therefore, decision-makers and their decisions in a healthy way and to be able to give the option of producing the positive and negative aspects of these options to determine which is a method. The main element that is tried to be protected with EIA is the environment and the assets in this environment.

It is clear that due to the complex nature of environmental decision-making processes, public authorities have a wide discretion. In this context, it is not the duty of the Constitutional Court to check the correctness of the decision made by public authorities on the construction and operation of a hydroelectric power plant in the area in question. However, it is important to determine whether there are guarantees that will serve to establish the necessary balance between the fundamental rights of the individual and the public interest in question in the process, and whether the procedural guarantees mentioned in the context of environmental issues are observed in determining whether the specified obligation is fulfilled Decisively.

In the concrete case, the applicant has no claim that his effective participation in the project process was not ensured. The applicant stated that an impossible commitment had been made in relation to the project, that the water pledged to be left in the creek bed could not be given due to the storage made in the upper part of the project, and that this issue was not included in the expert report. In addition, the applicant stated that the pond for which the tender was made was not mentioned in the EIA report and that these issues were not taken into account by the court of instance and claimed that an incomplete trial was conducted.

Both the administrative sanction decisions applied due to the release of water below the amount of environmental flow committed for the project, and the determinations contained in the internal correspondence of the administrations that the amount of committed water was not released, indicate that adequate and careful examination was not carried out in the concrete case during the process of making a positive decision of the Tue and conducting a trial on it. Although the applicant had a fundamental objection that his downstream water rights would be interrupted and that the water promised to be left in the streambed would not be given due to the pond planned to be established, no assessment was made by the courts of instance on these issues.

The concrete terms of reference of the public authorities of the applicant and the applicant’s basic claims a fair balance between the interests of the public in the matter of determining whether it is understood that they find important. Despite this, the applicant’s claims in question have not been evaluated by the courts of instance.

As a result, it was assessed that the public authorities did not approach the incident with due care, did not properly assess the public and individual interests at stake in the incident, and the public authorities did not fulfill their positive obligations in the context of the right to respect for private life.

The Constitutional Court has decided that the right to respect for private life has been violated on the grounds described.

 

By clicking here, you can access our other article examples and petition examples.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir