Anasayfa » Blog » Violation Of Property Rights Due To Non-Complimentary Losses Of Monetary Rights Due To Unlawful Delay Of Appointment

Violation Of Property Rights Due To Non-Complimentary Losses Of Monetary Rights Due To Unlawful Delay Of Appointment

Events

Although the applicants, who started to work as assistant labor inspectors, were successful in the labor inspector qualification written and oral exams, they were not appointed to the labor inspector position. The applicants applied to the Presidency of the Labor Inspection Board with a request to be appointed to the vacant positions of labor inspector. Thereupon, the applicants filed lawsuits in the administrative courts demanding the cancellation of these transactions and the payment of the monetary rights deprived from the date on which the title of inspector was acquired, together with the legal interest. Administrative courts have annulled the procedures for refusal of requests to be appointed as labor inspectors. Although the Administrative Courts decided that the monetary rights that the applicants were deprived of should be paid to the applicants together with the legal interest, they reached different conclusions in terms of the date on which the monetary rights would be calculated. While some Administrative Courts decided to pay the monetary rights that the applicants were deprived of as of the date on which they were entitled to be appointed as labor inspectors, some other Administrative Courts ruled that the deprived monetary rights should be calculated from the date of application to the administration.

The regional administrative court that examined the appeal request of the parties, on the other hand, rejected the appeal requests, but corrected the paragraphs of this provision in the judgments that the monetary rights of the applicants were calculated from the date they were entitled to be appointed as labor inspector, so that the monetary rights should be calculated from the date of application to the administration.

allegations

The applicants allege that their right to property has been violated because the loss of monetary rights suffered due to the unlawful delay in their appointment from assistant labor inspector to the position of labor inspector.

Court’s Evaluation

In the concrete case, it was determined by the decisions of the Administrative Courts, which passed the appeal control, that the delay in the appointment of the applicants to the labor inspectorate was unlawful. The fact that the delay in the appointment proceedings was unlawful showed that the interference with the applicants’ property rights was devoid of legal basis. Therefore, it was concluded that the violation of the right to property was determined by the administrative courts, and therefore, an examination was made whether the violation was remedied or not.

Although the cancellation of the administrative procedure and the completion of the appointment of the applicants alleviated their grievances, they did not completely relieve them. In order for the grievance to be eliminated in real terms, the damages caused by the violation of the applicants’ right to property must also be compensated. It has been understood that the applicants have filed a full remedy action in order to remedy the violation of the right to property. Some administrative courts have ruled that the monetary rights envisaged for this position should be paid to the applicants as of the date on which the applicants were entitled to be appointed as labor inspector. However, the regional administrative court fixed the date of calculation of monetary rights as the date of administrative application. According to the regional administrative court, the date of administrative application should be taken as a basis, since it is not clear in the concrete case how long the time required for the completion of the appointment procedures is. Some administrative courts, inspired by this reasoning of the regional administrative court, decided to take the date of administrative application as the date of calculation of monetary rights.

This view of the regional administrative court led to a contradiction in the decisions. In this context, the regional administrative court rejected the administrative court’s application of the administration’s appeal without giving any additional reasons. In the decisions of the administrative courts, it was determined that the administration was delayed beyond the reasonable in the realization of the appointment procedures. In fact, it was stated in the decisions of the regional administrative court that the applicants were not appointed as labor inspectors within a reasonable time.

On the other hand, the interpretation of the regional administrative court imposed the requirement of applying to the administration for appointment to the applicants who fulfilled all their obligations and were successful in the examination. However, in the legislation, it is foreseen that the assistant labor inspectors who successfully pass the proficiency exam will be automatically appointed as inspectors by the administration. Moreover, the administration did not find any defense to the contrary. Therefore, the approach of the regional administrative court gave the administration a discretionary power that was not even foreseen in the legislation.

In a state of law, the administration is under the obligation to remedy the violations caused by the unlawful transactions. Administration; In accordance with the principle of reinstatement ( restitutio in integrum ), the person is obliged to bring the situation as close as possible to the situation in which the person will be, if the unlawful transaction is not established. In this respect, it cannot be said that the administration has fully fulfilled its obligations to remedy the violation by appointing the applicants as labor inspectors. In order for the violation to be fully remedied, if there had been no unlawful delay, in the ordinary course of the administrative process, the monetary loss of rights arising from the date on which the applicants will be appointed as labor inspector must also be compensated.

Article 5 of the Constitution also imposes a duty on the state to take deterrent measures to prevent violations of rights and freedoms. The interpretation of the regional administrative court not only prevented the full compensation of the losses incurred due to the interference with the property rights of the applicants, but also rendered the deterrent feature of the compensation case ineffective against the establishment of unlawful action.

As a result, the complete elimination of the violation detected by the cancellation of the proceedings regarding the rejection of the request for appointment as a labor inspector was prevented due to the contradictory interpretation of the regional administrative court and some administrative courts. In this case, it is accepted that the violation of the property right continues.

The Constitutional Court decided that the right to property had been violated for the reasons explained.

 

You can reach our other article samples and petition samples by clicking here.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir