Anasayfa » Blog » Violation Of The Right To Personal Freedom And Security Due To An Unlawful Judicial Control Measure

Violation Of The Right To Personal Freedom And Security Due To An Unlawful Judicial Control Measure

Events

The applicant was detained and arrested on the allegation that he participated in an illegal demonstration march, which was stated to have been carried out at the call of an armed terrorist organization. In the public case brought against the applicant, the 2nd High Criminal Court decided to release the applicant with the prohibition of leaving the country and the judicial control measure not to leave the residence. At the end of the trial, the court decided to acquit him of membership in a terrorist organization and other crimes, to be punished for propaganda for a terrorist organization due to his social media posts, and to postpone the announcement of the verdict. Upon the finalization of the acquittal, the applicant filed a lawsuit demanding pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages. The 6th High Criminal Court decided to pay the applicant 6.330.76 TL for pecuniary damages, 12.000 TL for non-pecuniary damages and 2.199.69 TL for attorney’s fees. the applicant; stated that the compensation awarded and the attorney’s fee were low and that compensation should be awarded due to the judicial control measure, and applied for the appeal. The regional court of appeals decided to reject the appeal on the merits, correcting the moral compensation as 4,000 TL and the attorney’s fee as 1,240 TL.

allegations

the applicant; He claimed that his rights to a fair trial, personal freedom and security and property rights were violated because the compensation paid due to the detention and detention measure was insufficient, the claim for compensation within the scope of judicial control measure was not accepted, and the attorney’s fee was reduced by the regulation.

Court’s Evaluation

In the concrete case, it should be determined whether the statement of the secret witness contains concrete facts. The claim that the applicant participated in the action, which took place upon the calls of the armed terrorist organization and in which acts of violence took place, was based on the statement of a secret witness. The secret witness was shown the images taken during the action in question, and the anonymous witness identified the applicant from these images. It is clear that this diagnosis includes a concrete fact. Considering the determination that the applicant shared an illegal action photo on his social media account, it was seen that there was a strong indication that a crime had been committed. However, it should be evaluated whether the judicial control measure applied against the applicant has a legitimate aim.

According to the third paragraph of Article 19 of the Constitution, the arrest warrant may be issued in order to prevent escape or the destruction or alteration of evidence. Judicial control measure not to leave the residence -as an alternative to arrest-can only be given for these purposes stipulated in the Constitution. The aforementioned measure is a judicial measure, in particular, aimed at preventing the escape of suspects or accused persons. According to paragraph (1) of Article 109 of the Criminal Procedure Code No. 5271, in case of existence of reasons for arrest, it may be decided to put the person under judicial control instead of being arrested. Therefore, in the presence of reasons for detention and only in cases where the detention will not be proportional, judicial control measures can be applied.

However, the reasons for detention are regulated in Article 100 of the Law No. 5271. According to this, the reasons for detention are strong suspicion that the suspect or the accused escapes, hides or there are concrete facts that raise the suspicion of escaping, that the suspect or the accused destroys, hides or changes the evidence, and attempts to exert pressure on the witness, victim or others. The aforementioned legitimate aims of detention also apply to judicial control. In this context, in terms of judicial control measures, it should be evaluated whether the aims of avoiding escape or the destruction or alteration of evidence, pressure on witnesses, victims or others are put forward.

In the concrete case, the court of instance clearly stated that there was no suspicion of escape while deciding to put the applicant under judicial control. It has not made an assessment in terms of the aims of preventing the destruction or alteration of evidence and the pressure on witnesses, victims or others. However, in the concrete case, the evidence was collected with the completion of the investigation. Therefore, the applicant has no suspicion of obscuring the evidence. In addition, since there is a confidential witness in the case, it is not possible for the applicant to put pressure on the witness. The severity of the penalty stipulated in the law regarding the alleged crime and the fact that the alleged crime is one of the crimes that can be considered as a reason for arrest by law may justify the applicant’s being subjected to this measure in the first place.

In addition, since it was concluded that the applicant was subjected to a procedure contrary to the principles set forth in the third paragraph of Article 19 of the Constitution due to an unlawful judicial control measure, the ninth paragraph of Article 19 of the Constitution can be applied in the concrete case. However, in Articles 141 and the following of Law No. 5271, judicial control is not counted among the protection measures for which compensation can be claimed. The court of first instance did not evaluate the applicant’s request regarding the judicial control measure in the compensation case filed by the applicant, while the court of appeal stated that the judicial control measure could not be included in the compensation calculation. The Court of Cassation also decided that the compensation claim arising from the judicial control measure in the form of not leaving the residence should be rejected.

The Constitutional Court has decided that the right to liberty and security of person has been violated for the reasons explained.

 

You can reach our other article samples and petition samples by clicking here.

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir