Anasayfa » Blog » How Should The Heirs File The Action For Cancellation Of Deed Due To Incapacity

How Should The Heirs File The Action For Cancellation Of Deed Due To Incapacity

HOW SHOULD THE HEIRS FILE THE ACTION FOR CANCELLATION OF DEED DUE TO INCAPACITY?

As known; Ownership in cooperation (association) is the state of joint ownership of a property or right by persons who have a partnership bond between them pursuant to the law or the contracts specified in the law.

This type of ownership (partnership) regulated in 701 of the Turkish Civil Code No. 4721 does not have a legal personality, nor does each of the partners have a direct right on the goods. Ownership as a whole belongs to all partners. In other words, one of the partners does not have separate property or right ownership until the partnership is liquidated, and it is the rightful partnership. In the mentioned property type, the owners are not shareholders, but partners, since their property shares are not separated. This rule is explained in Article 701 (.. The ownership of the property of those who jointly own the goods due to the community formed in accordance with the law and the contracts stipulated in the law is joint ownership. In the ownership of the cooperation, the partners do not have a determined share, but the right of each is common to all the goods entering the partnership.). In case of cooperation (association), due to this feature of the property, there is a compulsory friendship between the partners. If it is not specified who will be authorized to act on behalf of the partnership in the law or in the agreement establishing the ownership in case of cooperation (association), it is obligatory for the partners (participants) to take a unanimous decision and act together in all transactions, except for the right to request the liquidation of the partnership. Article 702/2 of the TMK has made a clear provision in this regard. However, the explained rule has been partially softened in the judicial practice. (11.10. As a matter of fact, this view has been adopted in the scientific field as well. In the concrete case, it is understood that the plaintiffs filed the lawsuit with the request of cancellation and registration of the title deed in proportion to their inheritance shares, and that there are heirs out of the lawsuit. It is undisputed that in the lawsuit filed with the claim of legal incompetence, all the heirs representing the estate should act together and file the lawsuit or that one of the heirs should file the lawsuit with a willingness to return to the estate. (MK 640.art.) In that case, since the lawsuit filed by the plaintiffs based on the claim of legal incompetence at the share rate is not possible to be heard, it is not correct to accept the lawsuit while it should be rejected by the court (Court of Appeals 1st Civil Chamber – Decision: 2015/8078). It is understood that the plaintiffs filed the lawsuit with the request of cancellation and registration of title deed in proportion to their inheritance shares, and there are heirs out of the lawsuit. It is undisputed that in the lawsuit filed with the claim of legal incompetence, all the heirs representing the estate should act together and file the lawsuit or that one of the heirs should file the lawsuit with a willingness to return to the estate. (MK 640.art.) In that case, since the lawsuit filed by the plaintiffs based on the claim of legal incompetence at the share rate is not possible to be heard, it is not correct to accept the lawsuit while it should be rejected by the court (Court of Appeals 1st Civil Chamber – Decision: 2015/8078). It is understood that the plaintiffs filed the lawsuit with the request of cancellation and registration of title deed in proportion to their inheritance shares, and there are heirs out of the lawsuit. It is undisputed that in the lawsuit filed with the claim of legal incompetence, all the heirs representing the estate should act together and file the lawsuit or that one of the heirs should file the lawsuit with a willingness to return to the estate. (MK 640.art.) In that case, since the lawsuit filed by the plaintiffs based on the claim of legal incompetence at the share rate is not possible to be heard, it is not correct to accept the lawsuit while it should be rejected by the court (Court of Appeals 1st Civil Chamber – Decision: 2015/8078). It is undisputed that in the lawsuit filed with the claim of legal incompetence, all the heirs representing the estate should act together and file the lawsuit or that one of the heirs should file the lawsuit with a willingness to return to the estate. (MK 640.art.) In that case, since the lawsuit filed by the plaintiffs based on the claim of legal incompetence at the share rate is not possible to be heard, it is not correct to accept the lawsuit while it should be rejected by the court (Court of Appeals 1st Civil Chamber – Decision: 2015/8078). It is undisputed that in the lawsuit filed with the claim of legal incompetence, all the heirs representing the estate should act together and file the lawsuit or that one of the heirs should file the lawsuit with a willingness to return to the estate. (MK 640.art.) In that case, since the lawsuit filed by the plaintiffs based on the claim of legal incompetence at the share rate is not possible to be heard, it is not correct to accept the lawsuit while it should be rejected by the court (Court of Appeals 1st Civil Chamber – Decision: 2015/8078).

The original and joined cases are related to the title deed cancellation and registration request. The court decided to reject the case on the grounds that the legator was competent on the date of the transfer and the alleged fraud could not be proven. According to the date of death of the legator, his estate is subject to co-ownership. It is fixed with the scope of the file where there is another heir other than the plaintiff. Incompetence, abuse of power of attorney, fault-cheating-gabin etc., apart from cases such as tort collusion and prevention of confiscation arising from property made against the estate. If all heirs representing the estate open the case together by acting together in such cases, and also, if one of the heirs files a lawsuit as a return to the estate, the consent of all heirs in the lawsuit is provided, otherwise, it is undisputed that the estate will have to be represented and executed by the representative to be appointed (TMK 640 art.). In the concrete case, it cannot be said that there is no opportunity to hear the lawsuit filed by the plaintiff against the non-heir based on legal reasons of incapacity and fraud, at the rate of the inheritance share. On the other hand, since no lawsuit has been filed on behalf of the estate, appointing a representative to the estate and continuing the trial does not make it possible to hear the lawsuit filed in proportion to the share (Court of Appeals 1st Civil Chamber – Decision: 2020/3302). It cannot be said that there is no possibility of hearing the lawsuit filed by the claimant against the non-heir based on legal reasons of incompetence and fraud, at the rate of the inheritance share. On the other hand, since no lawsuit has been filed on behalf of the estate, appointing a representative to the estate and continuing the trial does not make it possible to hear the lawsuit filed in proportion to the share (Court of Appeals 1st Civil Chamber – Decision: 2020/3302). It cannot be said that there is no possibility of hearing the lawsuit filed by the claimant against the non-heir based on legal reasons of incompetence and fraud, at the rate of the inheritance share. On the other hand, since no lawsuit has been filed on behalf of the estate, appointing a representative to the estate and continuing the trial does not make it possible to hear the lawsuit filed in proportion to the share (Court of Appeals 1st Civil Chamber – Decision: 2020/3302).

Bir yanıt yazın

E-posta adresiniz yayınlanmayacak. Gerekli alanlar * ile işaretlenmişlerdir