PENAL CONDITION OR PENALTY CONDITION IN THE LAW OF OBLIGATIONS
(Y3HD-K.2020/3730)
He used the concept of ” penalty clause ” in Articles 158-161 of the Code of Obligations No. 818 (818 p. BK) , and preferred the concept of ” penalty condition ” in Articles 179-182 of the Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 (6098 p. TBK).
The penal clause is the act that the debtor undertakes to perform against the creditor if he does not perform his original debt at all or properly in the future. Therefore, the penal clause is an accessory act that can only arise from the breach of the original debt. If the debtor has committed to pay a penal clause, the creditor will now have the opportunity to obtain compensation without having to claim any damage or to prove the extent of the damage. Because the penal clause is a predetermined fixed amount (fixed) compensation that should be given in case of breach of the debt. The nature of the original debt is not important for the penal clause to be decided; As well as a debt to give, a penal clause can be decided for debts of doing or not doing (Tekinay Law of Obligations General Provisions, 7th Edition, Istanbul 1993, p. 341-343).
In addition, the penal clause has essentially two main purposes. One of them is to compel the debtor to perform and thus to secure the performance of the original debt; the other is to determine the damage that will arise from the non-performance of the debt in advance and in a lump sum way. Apart from these two main purposes, another purpose of the penal clause is to enable the debtor to easily withdraw from the contract by paying the penal clause in the penal clause preventing performance (Penal Clause in Turkish Private Law (UK. m. 158-161), Ankara 2003, p. .40-42). In our law, the types of penal clauses are regulated as optional penal clause, penal clause added to performance, and penal clause (return penalty) instead of performance.
optional penal clause; 6098 p. TBK. m. 179 f. According to the provision of I (818 p. BK. art. 158 f. I); “If a penalty has been agreed for the non-performance of a contract at all or as required, the creditor may request either the performance of the debt or the penalty, unless otherwise agreed in the contract”. According to this provision, the parties may have agreed in the contract that the debtor either performs his debt in accordance with the contract or that the penalty clause is paid. In this case, the debtor is obliged to act in accordance with the debt. However, if the debtor does not act in accordance with the debt, a sanction awaits him. This sanction is the payment of the penalty stipulated in the contract. This provision does not give the debtor the opportunity to get rid of the debt by acting contrary to the debt and thus paying the agreed penalty condition instead of the performance to be performed. If the debtor violates the debt, Although the penalty clause is determined in the contract, the creditor may demand the same performance from the debtor. Therefore, 6098 p. TBK. m. 179 f. In I (818 s. BK. m. 158 f I), the debtor has not given the authority to get rid of the debt by acting contrary to the debt, instead paying a penalty condition, but giving the creditor the authority to decide on this. In the event of the debtor’s misconduct, the creditor may demand performance as well as demand the payment of the penalty condition by waiving it. Here, there is an optional right granted to the creditor. For this reason, this type of penal clause is called “elective penal clause” (elective penal clause) (Law of Obligations General Provisions, 16th Edition, Ankara 2012, p. 773). In 158 f I), the debtor has given the creditor not the authority to get rid of the debt by acting contrary to the debt, instead paying the penalty condition, but the authority to decide on this. In the event of the debtor’s misconduct, the creditor may demand performance as well as demand the payment of the penalty condition by waiving it. Here, there is an optional right granted to the creditor. For this reason, this type of penal clause is called “elective penal clause” (elective penal clause) (Law of Obligations General Provisions, 16th Edition, Ankara 2012, p. 773). In 158 f I), the debtor has given the creditor not the authority to get rid of the debt by acting contrary to the debt, instead paying the penalty condition, but the authority to decide on this. In the event of the debtor’s misconduct, the creditor may demand performance as well as demand the payment of the penalty condition by waiving it. Here, there is an optional right granted to the creditor. For this reason, this type of penal clause is called “elective penal clause” (elective penal clause) (Law of Obligations General Provisions, 16th Edition, Ankara 2012, p. 773).
Penalty clause added to performance; 6098 p. TBK. m. 179 f. II “If the penalty is determined for non-performance of the debt at the specified time or place, the creditor may also request the performance of the penalty together with the original debt, unless he has explicitly waived his right or accepted the performance without reservation”. According to this provision, if the debtor acts in breach of the debt, the creditor may demand both the same performance and the payment of the agreed penalty. Therefore, it is possible that the penalty clause can be demanded in addition to the exact performance (cumulative). Unlike the optional penalty clause, the creditor is not compelled to demand either the exact performance or the penalty. The creditor here has the power to claim both. If the debtor will receive a penalty condition in addition to the performance, the creditor does not require the loss condition in case of breach of the debt. Even if the creditor does not suffer any damage due to the breach of the debt, he may demand a penalty condition in addition to the performance. The penalty clause added to the performance does not necessitate the damage condition. Even if the creditor does not suffer any loss due to the debtor’s misconduct, he may demand the agreed penalty clause.
Penalty instead of performance (return penalty) ; 6098 p. TBK. m. l79 f. According to the provision of III (818 s. BK. m. 158 f. III), “The right of the debtor to prove that he is authorized to terminate the contract by rescission or termination by fulfilling the agreed penalty is reserved”. As we explained above, the purpose of the penalty clause is to ensure that the debtor acts in accordance with the debt. However, here, the debtor has the opportunity to get rid of the debt by paying the penalty condition instead of performing the debt. In other words, here the debtor does not act contrary to the debt, he can return from the contract by paying the penalty condition instead of performing the debt. Therefore, the penalty clause replaces the performance (KILIÇOĞLU, supra, p. 775-777).
As for the delay compensation issue; 6098 p. TBK. m. The delay indemnity regulated in 118/I (818 p. BK. art. 106/2) aims to cover the damage suffered by the creditor due to the late performance of the debt and is aimed at ensuring the creditor’s interest in the performance of the debt without delay. For this reason, delay compensation can be demanded together with the performance, even if the performance is fulfilled after the default and a reservation (reservation) has not been put forward, it can be demanded and sued after the performance, even if it is not demanded in the performance lawsuit, the delay compensation can be sued separately. (M…./…, Law of Obligations General Provisions, C.1, Istanbul 2011, p.488) Accepting the contrary causes the default to remain unsanctioned for the debtor. It has brought the provision that the defaulting debtor is “obligated to compensate the damage suffered by the creditor due to the late performance of the debt”. delay compensation,
The damage to be compensated for delay indemnity is a kind of positive damage and it expresses the difference between the situation of the creditor’s assets if the debt is fulfilled without default and the situation he is in as a result of delayed performance.
In the concrete case; There is no dispute between the parties regarding the lease agreement with a starting date of 27.09.2005 and a term of 5+5 years. In the 20th article of the lease agreement, “the lessee is obliged to pay the rent within five days at the latest from the date of the contract.
It accepts and undertakes to pay a 10% delay penalty if it does not pay on time.” formatted. Although the plaintiff lessor has requested a monthly delay penalty of 10% in the execution proceedings, in addition to the unpaid rent receivables, according to article 20 of the contract until the enforcement proceedings date; Considering that the delay penalty is not explicitly stated as 10% per month in the contract, it is not correct to apply a delay penalty of 10% of the rent receivable for each month, while the delay penalty should be applied annually.