8. Department of Law 2019/60 E. , 2021/2391 K .
“text of jurisprudence”
COURT : Court of First Instance
CASE TYPE : Ecrimisil
At the end of the trial between the parties and in the case described above, the Court decided to partially accept the case, and after the decision was appealed by the defendant’s attorney, the Department examined the file and Decisively considered it.
K A R A R
The plaintiff’s attorney; The attorney and the defendant are the owners of the immovables subject to the lawsuit by transferring from the muristen, but the defendant’s attorney did not pay the rent that falls on the share of the attorney and requested that a decision be made with the award and sued.
The defendant’s attorney; defended the dismissal of the case.
The court has decided to partially accept the case and the verdict has been appealed by the defendant’s attorney.
The case is related to the request for Decriminalization between the stakeholders.
1. According to the content of the file, the alternation of case documents and trial minutes, the available evidence was decided by the Court at its discretion, and if there was no error, the other appeals of the defendant’s attorney, which are outside the scope of the following paragraph, were not considered on the spot.
2. As for the other appeals of the defendant’s attorney; As is known, the stakeholder who cannot benefit from the immovable property in shared ownership may always request the prevention and / or compensation of access to his share from other stakeholders or stakeholders who are obstacles.
As a rule, stakeholders cannot ask for compensation from each other unless they are banned. The realization of the intifada prohibition condition also depends on the fact that the claimant stakeholder’s desire to benefit from the immovable property or income subject to the case has been notified to the respondent stakeholder before the required period of time. However, there are a number of exceptions to this rule that have arisen with established judicial practice. These; immovable state property to be the subject of the case, the adequate payment is requested immovable (vineyards, orchards, such as giving or natural product (business, residential etc) to be obtained and legal fruition rented places, joint stakeholders in the real estate and The Fellowship of others who occupied this whole place to the denial of claims, the agreement between stakeholders for the benefit of all stakeholders as a result of use of immovable joint, or the presence of specific departments, other stakeholders earlier this against immovable by the plaintiff relating to the Prevention of elatma, elimination of partnership, ecrimisil and similar cases are cases of opening or enforcement proceedings have been made. In addition, in terms of the product brought by the immovable property, the products formed spontaneously; mowed grass, collected nuts, tea, or businesses established by muris or businesses that generate income in their own right, in case of occupation, there is no need to create the condition of prohibition from intifada.
For this reason, the realization of the condition of prohibition from the intifada will be sought with the exceptions listed in terms of the immovables subject to the case, and the claim that the condition of prohibition from the intifada has occurred can be proven with all kinds of evidence.
In the concrete case, although the Court accepted that the intifada prohibition condition occurred as a result of the dissolution of the partnership lawsuit filed before the case in hand, the defendant’s request to have witnesses heard was rejected; the mentioned Ankara 3.When the settlement of the partnership file numbered 2010/812 of the Civil Court of Peace was examined, it was seen that the case was opened by the Second respondent in the case at hand and other stakeholders who are out of the case, and the plaintiff at hand took part as a defendant in the settlement of the partnership case.
Less of the above-mentioned principles and the content of the file, according to the partnership by the parties that the plaintiff be opened from the direction of the elimination of the plaintiff’s condition will perform barred from the case of the Intifada; the answer to the suit case and in Court, the witness based on the evidence, the parties were given time to present a list of witnesses after the intifada to be achieved by determining as to whether the condition is barred from should be decided according to the result; and in justification of the outcome in writing with the unprecedented right to go yanilgili, provision had therefore corruption.
CONCLUSION : The decision of the defendant’s attorney to accept the appeals for the reasons explained in the bet (2), the rejection of other appeals for the reasons explained in subparagraph (1) and the decision of the Provisional 3 of the CCP No. 6100. article 428 of the HUMK No. 1086 by sending. in accordance with Article 440 /III-1, 2, 3 and 4 of the HUMK. it was unanimously decided on 17.03.2021 that the way of correcting the decision against the announcement was closed in accordance with the provisions, and the advance fee was returned to the appellant upon request
You can reach our other articles, sample decisions and petitions by clicking here